Midseason rookie rankings: Sauce Gardner or Chris Olave at No. 1?

2 years ago 48

7:00 AM ET

  • Multiple Contributors

The 2022 NFL rookie people continues to look highly beardown through 9 weeks. Four moving backs are already implicit 400 rushing yards, portion six receivers person surpassed 300 receiving yards. Nine first-year defenders person aggregate sacks, 7 person aggregate interceptions, and the people has combined for 48 sacks and 28 picks to date. Four quarterbacks person gotten astatine slightest 1 start, and teams are getting mostly effectual play from their rookie violative linemen.

So however bash the rookies stack up truthful far? Let's fertile the apical 10 astatine midseason. We polled our ain Matt Bowen, Jeff Legwold, Matt Miller and Jordan Reid for their idiosyncratic lists and combined them to marque a statement ranking of the apical 10 rookies. Our experts past weighed successful connected each subordinate who made the list, on with a fewer who fell conscionable short. Finally, they picked retired a riser to watch, an underperforming first-rounder and an overperforming late-rounder, and took a speedy look astatine the first-year backmost situations.

Let's leap successful astatine No. 1 with a standout cornerback.

Jump to:
Top 10 | Just missed
Big questions

1. Sauce Gardner, CB, New York Jets

Stats: 44 tackles, 2 INTs, 13 passes defended
Drafted: No. 4

Why he's here: Gardner had a spot of a learning-curve infinitesimal connected Sunday erstwhile helium allowed a 42-yard reception to Bills receiver Stefon Diggs connected Buffalo's archetypal play from scrimmage. But past helium did what helium has done each play -- settee successful and bash prime work, including hauling successful his 2nd interception of the season. His completion percent against implicit anticipation is minus-10.1%, per NFL Next Gen Stats. -- Legwold

Going forward: He mightiness person gotten disconnected to a dilatory commencement to the season, but helium has since emerged arsenic not conscionable the champion rookie cornerback but besides 1 of the NFL's champion cornerbacks successful general. Look for much of the aforesaid the remainder of the mode arsenic Gardner continues to get acclimated to the pro game. He could decorativeness 2022 arsenic 1 of the apical 5 corners successful the NFL and is surely a Pro Bowl candidate. -- Miller


2. Chris Olave, WR, New Orleans Saints

Stats: 43 catches, 618 yards, 2 TDs
Drafted: No. 11

Why he's here: Smooth successful the way histrion and showcasing the vertical agelong quality to interval past defenders, Olave has impressed arsenic a perimeter people aboriginal successful his NFL career. The rookie has already logged 7 explosive-play receptions this season, and his quality to abstracted opens up opportunities astatine the 2nd level of the field, too. -- Bowen

Going forward: Despite the Saints' inconsistencies astatine quarterback, Olave has rapidly turned into the team's apical pass-catcher and leads each rookies with 14.9 aerial yards per target. With Michael Thomas (toe) and Jarvis Landry (ankle) battling injuries, expect the rookie to proceed to play a large role. -- Reid

play

0:58

Daniel Dopp and Field Yates hold that Chris Olave has had a dynamic commencement to his NFL career.


3. Dameon Pierce, RB, Houston Texans

Stats: 148 carries, 678 rushing yards, 20 catches, 98 receiving yards, 4 full TDs
Drafted: No. 107

Why he's here: Pierce is the discourtesy successful Houston, and adjacent arsenic defenses load up to halt him, his almighty benignant of moving keeps the chains moving. His 40 rushing archetypal downs are not lone acold and distant the astir among rookies but besides 4th wide among each NFL players. Pierce's power, imaginativeness and effort arsenic a runner are outstanding, and he's a legit Offensive Rookie of the Year candidate. -- Miller

Going forward: He is sixth successful the league successful rushing, has a 75-yard touchdown tally this play and consistently pounds retired the yards aft interaction (2.1 per carry) with a increasing heap of breached tackles already successful his wake. The aboriginal is agleam for Pierce. -- Legwold


4. Kenneth Walker III, RB, Seattle Seahawks

Stats: 111 carries, 570 rushing yards, 12 catches, 48 receiving yards, 7 full TDs
Drafted: No. 41

Why he's here: He didn't statesman the play arsenic the starter, but Walker has rapidly entrenched himself arsenic 1 of the Seahawks' cardinal violative playmakers. With 7 rushing TDs -- each coming successful the past 5 games -- he's connected a speedy way to outplaying his second-round draught slot. He joins the Jets' Breece Hall arsenic the lone rookies averaging implicit 5 yards per carry. -- Reid

Going forward: Walker is the person for this Seattle discourtesy arsenic a rookie with seasoned traits. His lateral quickness, assemblage power and finishing powerfulness amusement up precocious successful games. In the 4th quarter, helium has scored six of his 7 touchdowns and is averaging 7 yards per tote. And helium tin grip the measurement to deterioration down opposing defenses. -- Bowen


5. Tariq Woolen, CB, Seattle Seahawks

Stats: 31 tackles, 4 INTs, 8 passes defended, 1 TD, 2 fumble recoveries, 1 blocked kick
Drafted: No. 153

Why he's here: Another Seahawk connected the database here. Woolen has played each antiaircraft drawback for the Seahawks successful six of the past 7 games. And for a subordinate immoderate expected to instrumentality a small much clip to get acclimated -- helium was a cornerback for lone 1 afloat play successful assemblage -- helium has been calm successful coverage. He consistently makes plays connected the ball, intercepting oregon defending 20% of the targets thrown his way, per NFL Next Gen Stats. -- Legwold

Going forward: Woolen has the length, physicality and instincts to excel nary substance the assignment. He has a beardown Defensive Rookie of the Year case, and helium looks similar a Pro Bowl-caliber subordinate and a franchise gathering artifact moving forward. -- Miller


6. Garrett Wilson, WR, New York Jets

Stats: 42 catches, 521 yards, 2 TDs
Drafted: No. 10

Why he's here: A premier people successful New York's defined walk game, Wilson is simply a abrupt mover with dynamic playmaking traits. And his caller tally of accumulation shows his quality to enactment each 3 levels of the way tree. He trails lone Green Bay's Romeo Doubs among rookie wide receivers with 4.7 yards aft the drawback per reception, and helium has picked up 25 archetypal downs. -- Bowen

Going forward: Quarterback Zach Wilson has been inconsistent since returning from injury, but his rookie wideout is already 1 of his favourite targets. Garrett Wilson's 68 targets way lone Olave among rookies (35 of which came from Zach Wilson). Finding the extremity portion is the adjacent measurement of his development, but the yards are already coming successful bunches for the Ohio State product. -- Reid

play

1:04

Matt Bowen breaks down Garrett Wilson's show against the Bills successful Week 9.


7. Jack Jones, CB, New England Patriots

Stats: 24 tackles, 2 INTs, 5 passes defended, 1 TD, 1 forced fumble, 1 fumble recovery
Drafted: No. 121

Why he's here: Who would person thought that Jones, a fourth-round draught pick, would beryllium a seamless replacement for premier escaped cause J.C. Jackson successful New England? Well, Patriots manager Bill Belichick, for one. Jones has been a stone prima arsenic a nickel cornerback and is the Patriots' semipermanent aboriginal astatine the position. When teams people him successful coverage, they person minus-11.9 expected points added, which trails conscionable Gardner among rookie corners (NFL Next Gen Stats). -- Miller

Going forward: It's hard for immoderate rookie to gain Belichick's trust, particularly connected defense, but Jones has done conscionable that. He has been particularly effectual successful the Patriots' portion looks and connected peculiar teams, and his explosiveness means helium volition artifact immoderate kicks successful his career. -- Legwold


8. Aidan Hutchinson, DE, Detroit Lions

Stats: 20 tackles, 4.5 sacks, 1 INT, 22 pressures
Drafted: No. 2

Why he's here: Hutchinson has been 1 of the fewer agleam spots for a defence that has struggled mightily this season, displaying tremendous effort and showcasing a knack of getting to the QB. He has made game-changing plays for Detroit, including an interception of Aaron Rodgers astatine the extremity enactment connected Sunday. -- Reid

Going forward: Watch for much interaction plays from Hutchinson versus the tally and the pass. We cognize helium tin acceptable an edge, with beardown manus usage and carnal play. And he's showing improvement arsenic a pass-rusher, too, with the quality to disrupt the pocket. -- Bowen


9. Tyler Linderbaum, C, Baltimore Ravens

Stats: 9 starts, 93.7% walk artifact triumph rate
Drafted: No. 25

Why he's here: Ravens manager John Harbaugh said Linderbaum is "all ball," and it's existent done 9 weeks. Baltimore is the league's No. 2 rushing squad (168.1 yards per game), acknowledgment successful portion to Linderbaum's 76.5% tally artifact triumph complaint (fifth among rookies). He has played each but 2 snaps this play (549 of 551). -- Legwold

Going forward: Much similar Kansas City's Creed Humphrey did past year, Linderbaum has solidified an violative enactment astatine center. He was considered 1 of the astir all-around coagulated players successful the 2022 draught class, but he's inactive exceeding expectations, playing arsenic 1 of the apical centers successful the league and perchance receiving Pro Bowl attention. -- Miller


10. Drake London, WR, Atlanta Falcons

Stats: 33 catches, 369 yards, 2 TDs
Drafted: No. 8

Why he's here: London has the 6-foot-4 carnal illustration to agelong the seams oregon isolate arsenic a bound people successful the walk game. London leads the Falcons successful routes tally (187) and targets (56), but Atlanta's deficiency of throwing measurement has constricted his full production. The Falcons are past successful pass-play percent astatine conscionable 46.9% and mean 22.3 walk attempts per game. So we inactive haven't seen London scope his rookie ceiling successful that offense. -- Bowen

Going forward: The archetypal receiver drafted this twelvemonth has flashed erstwhile fixed opportunity, making the astir of his relation successful a run-heavy offense. Twenty-two of his 33 catches person gone for a archetypal down, but much measurement could unfastened up different level of his game. -- Reid

Just missed

Travon Walker, DE, Jacksonville Jaguars: The No. 1 wide prime successful April's draught has flashed uncommon carnal traits, posting 2.5 sacks -- including 1.5 implicit his past 3 games -- an interception and 16 pressures. The Jaguars person asked a batch of him, too. Walker has dropped into sum connected 49 snaps this season. -- Legwold

Devin Lloyd, ILB, Jacksonville Jaguars: Lloyd leads each rookies successful tackles (69 aft 9 games), portion besides pulling down 2 interceptions, defending 7 passes and recovering a fumble. He was tossed into the heavy extremity close from the commencement aft getting drafted 27th wide and hasn't played less than 90% of the antiaircraft snaps successful immoderate game. -- Legwold

Charles Cross, OT, Seattle Seahawks: With chap rookie tackle Abraham Lucas connected the close side, Cross has started from Day 1 astatine near tackle successful a resurgent offense. The ninth wide prime has played each but 4 of the Seahawks' violative snaps, and his 89.0% walk artifact triumph complaint and 76.1% tally artifact triumph complaint some fertile among the league's apical six rookies. -- Legwold

Also received votes: Kyle Hamilton, George Pickens, Breece Hall, Jamaree Salyer, Jalen Pitre, Kaiir Elam, Derek Stingley Jr., Jaquan Brisker, Jordan Davis, Abraham Lucas

Which rookie is rising done 9 weeks?

Legwold: Abraham Lucas, OT, Seattle Seahawks (No. 72 pick). We conscionable talked astir Cross connected the near side, but Lucas has enactment immoderate prime train-coming-down-the-tracks moments connected the crippled portion connected the close side. His 92.9% walk artifact triumph complaint is tops among rookie tackles, 2nd among each rookie violative linemen (Linderbaum) and successful the apical 50 leaguewide. He saw much than 450 pass-block snaps successful his last play astatine Washington State, but Lucas is present besides showing a carnal beingness successful the tally game.


What is going connected with the rookie quarterbacks?

Bowen: Pittsburgh's Kenny Pickett -- the class' lone first-round QB -- has made immoderate mediocre decisions with the shot (eight interceptions), but I bash spot plentifulness of poise successful the pocket. He has completed 67.9% of his passes for 962 yards and 2 touchdowns. And helium does a bully occupation utilizing his mobility erstwhile necessary, scoring doubly much connected the ground.

The portion connected New England's Bailey Zappe shows america helium tin run arsenic a bushed passer, delivering the shot connected time. And Tennessee backmost Malik Willis' deficiency of throwing measurement makes it pugnacious to genuinely measure his advancement astatine this point.


Which first-rounder is underperforming close now?

Miller: Treylon Burks, WR, Tennessee Titans (No. 18 pick). Selected to beryllium the team's replacement for A.J. Brown, Burks has yet to unrecorded up to expectations. There were struggles successful grooming camp, and present Burks has been retired with a turf toed wounded since Week 5. Olave and Wilson person go go-to targets for their teams, but Burks hasn't produced overmuch for the Titans. He has conscionable 10 catches for 129 yards and zero touchdowns implicit 4 games played.


Which late-rounder is overperforming close now?

Reid: Jamaree Salyer, OT, Los Angeles Chargers (No. 195). Rashawn Slater is not an casual violative lineman to replace, but since stepping successful for the injured franchise near tackle, Salyer has been outstanding. The sixth-rounder has been accordant successful walk protection, posting an 89.2% walk artifact triumph complaint (fifth among rookies), but helium has been conscionable arsenic reliable arsenic a run-blocker.

Read Entire Article