Under a achromatic enactment structure successful the Virtua Voorhees Hospital parking lot, waitstaff served coconut-crusted shrimp and sushi rolls connected metallic trays. A three-piece jazz set played arsenic an invitation-only assemblage was treated to 3 unfastened bars and acquisition boxes of cocoa truffles, stacked successful tiers similar a wedding cake.
The gala previewed a caller $45 cardinal installation built to clasp a 90-ton cylindrical instrumentality that harnesses high-energy protons to zap crab cells with pencil-point precision.
South Jersey gained its archetypal proton therapy halfway done a associated task betwixt the infirmary and Penn Medicine, whose aesculapian and concern musculus is helping to alteration the portion into a premier investigating crushed for a costly attraction that is inactive being studied to spot if it’s amended than cheaper, modular radiation to combat astir cancers.
The Philadelphia portion is emerging arsenic a blistery spot for proton therapy, sitting astatine the bosom of the nation’s highest attraction of centers clustered betwixt New York and Washington, D.C.
The Voorhees facility, slated to unfastened by spring, gives the Philadelphia country its 2nd proton center. A Penn rival present proposes to unfastened a 3rd successful the city, though the plan is successful aboriginal stages. Penn, meanwhile, has extended its proton scope to Lancaster, wherever it opened a $48 cardinal proton halfway successful December.
Penn is already a planetary leader in this therapy. Through lucrative fiscal agreements with planetary manufacturers of proton technology, Penn says it has trained much than 70% of doctors present utilizing proton therapy astir the world.
These partnerships made Penn a starring recipient of manufacture wealth among hospitals nationwide, authorities records show.
Penn is besides a driving unit successful the technological probe that could yet settee an ongoing statement astir whether proton therapy really yields higher cure rates, greater longevity, oregon less harmful broadside effects. It is starring a intimately watched probe trial, mostly funded by the national government, comparing proton and accepted radiation therapy for bosom cancer. It’s progressive successful different for prostate cancer.
Penn’s existent enlargement reflects a rationale — which probe has yet to beryllium — that proton radiation is little toxic to the body, with less terrible broadside effects, reducing the chances of secondary cancers arsenic patients age.
“That’s going to instrumentality decades to prove. Do we privation to hold for that? No,” said James Metz, who chairs Penn’s radiation oncology department. “Our occupation astatine Penn is to propulsion the future.”
» READ MORE: What to cognize astir proton therapy, the costly and arguable crab radiation treatment
Mercedes-Benz oregon BMW?
Proton radiation works by delivering a beam of proton particles that stops astatine the tumor, truthful it’s little apt to harm adjacent steadfast tissue. Conventional radiation beams X-rays to the tumor and beyond, exposing adjacent insubstantial and organs to radiation. Still, the latest X-ray exertion is considered highly blase and often fractional the terms of proton therapy.
Penn radiation oncologist Justin E. Bekelman enactment the quality simply: “Both of these treatments are terrific. The question is, is 1 amended than the different and for whom? But it’s benignant of like, 1 is simply a Mercedes-Benz and 1 is simply a BMW.”
Some grounds shows advantages for proton therapy against rarer, hard-to-treat tumors successful delicate areas, specified arsenic the brain, spinal cord, and eye, but the verdict remains retired for much common diseases specified arsenic bosom oregon prostate cancer.
» READ MORE: For bosom crab patients, Penn researchers are comparing costly proton therapy with modular radiation
Critics telephone the proliferation of proton therapy centers the poster kid for profiteering successful the American wellness attraction system, wherever the newest, shiniest exertion drives up costs for everyone.
Who pays seems arsenic analyzable arsenic the exertion itself. Taxpayers are supporting the proliferation of proton therapy, which is wide covered for seniors relying connected Medicare for wellness insurance. But backstage insurers won’t screen proton radiation for the immense bulk of big crab patients, citing unproven benefits and exorbitant costs. They volition screen protons for pediatric cancers due to the fact that there’s a aesculapian statement that it’s little harmful to children’s processing tissues.
If objective trials yet amusement that protons pb to patients surviving longer with less broadside effects, insurers whitethorn beryllium compelled to pay.
“The exertion marches on, but the information isn’t yet in,” said Anthony Zietman, interim main of the Department of Radiation Oncology astatine Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School. “Penn is making a bet, and they whitethorn beryllium right.”
Caught betwixt doctors and insurers are patients similar Zachary Rizzuto, who was 37 years aged erstwhile an MRI recovered a grapefruit-sized tumor successful his lower, close brain.
After 2 surgeries and chemotherapy astatine Penn, Rizzuto’s doc recommended proton radiation treatment. But Rizzuto’s wellness security institution denied coverage, concluding it was “experimental” and “not much effective” than cheaper, modular radiation.
Rizzuto and his wife, Melissa, turned to GoFundMe to rise $125,554 for 33 proton attraction sessions astatine Penn. Penn required fractional of the wealth successful currency up front.
The couple, portion furious with their insurer, had implicit religion successful Penn’s aesculapian expertise.
“In my mind, UPenn was ever the God of medicine,” Melissa Rizzuto said.
Philly sits astatine the bosom of expansion
When Penn opened the Roberts Proton Therapy Center successful University City successful 2010, the $144 cardinal Philadelphia halfway was the archetypal successful the Mid-Atlantic — the lone 1 betwixt Boston and Florida — and 1 of conscionable six specified centers nationwide.
Today, determination are 41 proton therapy centers crossed the country, according to the National Association for Proton Therapy, a Virginia-based nonprofit founded successful 1990 to beforehand the treatment. Penn hails its Roberts Center arsenic “the largest successful the world,” with 5 attraction rooms that it says service astir 900 patients a year.
The manufacture group’s tracking shows 2 proton centers presently serving the full authorities of California. Meanwhile, the Philadelphia country is connected its mode to having three. Penn rival Jefferson Health is readying to physique a halfway successful North Philadelphia. Neither Jefferson’s planned 1 nor the Voorhees halfway is counted among the 41 progressive centers.
In the agelong betwixt Boston and Florida, wherever Penn erstwhile stood alone, determination are present 10 different centers up and running.
The explosive maturation worries Vikas Saini, a cardiologist and president of the Lown Institute, a deliberation vessel that examines quality, cost, and equity crossed wellness care. He said doctors are prescribing proton therapy successful a grey country — they deliberation it whitethorn beryllium amended for a diligent than the cheaper alternative, but there’s nary hard proof.
“Everybody knows the game: You get an approval, and you spell retired connected the market, past you grow the indications,” Saini said. “It’s called denotation creep, oregon scope creep.”
The bulk of patients receiving proton beam therapy successful the U.S. successful 2018 were treated for cancers for which the therapy is not considered medically indispensable by the American Society for Radiation Oncology, according to a survey successful the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA).
The 2022 survey recovered that astir of the therapy for the cancers for which grounds is sparse was paid for by Medicare, the government’s wellness security programme for seniors and radical with disabilities.
Medicare mostly covers proton therapy — astatine treble the outgo to taxpayers.
In 2022, Medicare paid astir $1,300 for each proton session, compared with little than $600 for each accepted radiation treatment. Slightly much than 40% of patients treated with protons astatine Penn are Medicare beneficiaries. Pennsylvania Medicaid, the government’s security programme for radical with constricted income, offers constricted sum for proton therapy, typically evaluated lone connected a case-by-case basis, according to Penn.
For prostate cancer, 1 of the astir communal cancers successful men, many backstage insurers pulled backmost connected sum for proton therapy aft studies, including one with Penn, showed small quality successful outcomes. Some centers mislaid money, defaulted connected loans, oregon went bankrupt.
Penn’s attack is different, its leaders say. For starters, Penn’s 2 caller facilities are smaller and little costly than the Roberts Center, which Penn says is profitable. Each has 1 attraction room, projected to dainty astir 180 patients a year.
Its interior projections amusement that determination are much than capable crab patients to dainty with protons, said Penn’s Metz, a starring adept successful the field.
Penn besides does not rely on a backstage equity spouse oregon lending banks, which insulates it from unit to thrust up diligent numbers to crook a profit, according to Metz.
“It allowed america arsenic physicians to truly research what’s the champion treatment,” helium said.
Proton therapy centers besides are bully for marketing, helium said.
“Many patients travel successful looking for protons, but galore times different treatments are close for them,” Metz said. “It really grows the wide volume.”
‘That’s a existent reddish flag’
During the VIP preview successful Voorhees backmost successful October, the assemblage of astir 150 turned toward the caller gathering for a lighting ceremonial arsenic acheronian fell. They counted backward from 10 and past strobes of red, blue, and achromatic illuminated the facade, acting similar a elephantine billboard.
“By shining our light, we’re letting our neighborhoods cognize that we are here,” said Dennis Pullin, Virtua president and CEO.
The infirmary promised that the archetypal 100 patients done the doorway would person an ornamental solid suncatcher arsenic a “symbol of healing and hope.”
Penn promotes its centers with descriptions similar “state-of-the-art,” “lifesaving,” and “leading-edge signifier of crab treatment.”
Penn’s websites accidental the attraction tin connection “fewer, milder broadside effects” and is “best” for bosom and prostate cancers, among others.
The web pages don’t admit that it is inactive moving studies to beryllium those assertions.
“They are making immoderate precise beardown claims based connected precise anemic evidence,” said Steven Woloshin, prof astatine the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice. “That’s a existent reddish flag.”
Penn trains doctors worldwide
Even as the technological verdict remains out, Penn made much wealth than immoderate different infirmary successful the U.S. from a starring shaper of proton technology, nationalist filings show.
Varian Medical Systems gave Penn astir $7.2 cardinal betwixt 2015 and 2021, according to an Inquirer reappraisal of information from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
Much of this wealth paid for Penn to bid different providers worldwide, Metz said. Roughly $2 cardinal went to research.
When Varian sells a caller proton center, the purchaser tin wage other to person Penn doctors bid their unit — astatine their tract oregon successful Philadelphia.
Penn has a akin grooming statement with different apical manufacturer, Ion Beam Applications, oregon IBA, Metz said.
“We really bid astir 70 percent of the radical successful the satellite doing protons,” said Metz, who besides has been a subordinate of advisory boards for some Varian and IBA.
Who pays? Sometimes, the patients
To get treated astatine Penn, the Rizzuto household had to crook to GoFundMe successful 2018 to wage for a therapy that their security refused to cover, citing a deficiency of evidence.
Zachary and Melissa Rizzuto were expecting their archetypal kid erstwhile Zachary began acting strangely.
The self-described neatnik would determination beverage into a cereal vessel — and support pouring. He stood frozen arsenic beverage spilled implicit the room counter. He dismissed it arsenic enactment stress. But arsenic helium continued to acquisition insignificant blackouts, his woman made him spot a doctor.
An MRI showed a encephalon tumor. Their daughter, Roxanne, was lone 3 months aged erstwhile a biopsy confirmed it was a uncommon and assertive tumor: anaplastic astrocytoma.
“I conscionable broke down. It was wholly devastating,” Zachary Rizzuto recalled recently. “You perceive encephalon tumor, and successful my mind, I’m thinking, ‘I don’t cognize however agelong I’m going to live.’”
The mates lives successful Florida but sought attraction astatine Penn, based connected its estimation for excellence and proximity to Melissa Rizzuto’s parents, who unrecorded astir 20 minutes extracurricular Philadelphia and helped attraction for Roxanne.
“Would helium person survived with the different treatment? Yes. Would helium beryllium capable to work, perchance speak, and function? Maybe not.”
After 2 surgeries to region the tumor, Zachary Rizzuto inactive had crab cells successful portions of his encephalon important to imaginativeness and memory. Their radiation oncologist astatine Penn prescribed proton therapy, assuring the mates that the beam’s precision would spare steadfast encephalon tissue.
Rizzuto would request much than 30 sessions astatine $3,805 each.
The mates had already flown into Philadelphia from their Fort Myers location successful February 2018 to commencement attraction erstwhile they learned that their wellness security company, UnitedHealthcare, had denied coverage.
Penn required they pay fractional of the full cost up-front — $66,777 — to statesman treatment. The mates turned to family, friends, and strangers to assistance them rise the wealth portion appealing to UnitedHealthcare.
“Zachary is simply a 37-year-old antheral successful highest wellness different than his tumor,” Melissa Rizzuto wrote successful a missive to UnitedHealthcare. “He has a 9-month-old girl and needs to support an due prime of beingness and cognitive relation successful bid to gain a surviving and attraction for his family.”
Penn doctors besides wrote appeals. “Proton therapy attraction for encephalon tumors targets tumor cells portion importantly reducing the harm of steadfast insubstantial surrounding the brain,” wrote Rizzuto’s doctor, Robert Lustig, who has since retired. UnitedHealthcare denied the appeals.
In an emailed connection to an Inquirer reporter, UnitedHealthcare spokesperson Maria Gordon Shydlo wrote that they trust connected “evidence-based protocols to marque these sum decisions.”
“We are committed to providing our members sum for safe, proven and clinically effectual wellness attraction services,” she wrote.
Zachary Rizzuto is suing UnitedHealthcare for wrongful denial of coverage. His lawyer contends that existent sum policies are arbitrary, pointing retired that UnitedHealthcare covers proton therapy for children younger than 19. The insurer besides sells plans for Medicare Advantage, which covers proton attraction for seniors, 65 and up.
Zietman, who specializes successful crab attraction astatine Massachusetts General Hospital, said it volition instrumentality galore objective studies with “thousands of patients” to find if protons are genuinely advantageous implicit accepted (X-ray) radiation. Both treatments, helium said, person technologically precocious wrong the past 3 decades.
“It’s not adjacent definite that protons are better. It mightiness adjacent beryllium worse,” Zietman said. “I deliberation mostly speaking for brains, it’s a precise bully treatment. But, determination are immoderate parts of the encephalon for which it whitethorn not be.”
Rizzuto has a tumor benignant that is expected to turn backmost someday, but for now, doctors see it to beryllium stable. There’s a tiny portion of tumor surgeons couldn’t remove, but encephalon scans truthful acold amusement it hasn’t grown.
He’s backmost moving afloat time. The couple’s daughter, an babe erstwhile Rizzuto was diagnosed, turned 5 years aged this past May.
Melissa Rizzuto said she’s convinced her hubby benefited from proton radiation. “Would helium person survived with the different treatment? Yes,” she said. “Would helium beryllium capable to work, perchance speak, and function? Maybe not.”
English (US)