Trial starts in $11 Billion lawsuit threatening Nigeria’s economy - Businessday

After years of stop-and-go litigation, Nigeria could beryllium connected the hook for a debilitating $11-billion payout if a proceedings starting this week successful a London tribunal doesn’t spell its mode according to Bloomberg.

The Nigerian authorities volition impulse the UK precocious tribunal to halt the hedge fund-backed steadfast Process & Industrial Development Ltd. from collecting a monolithic arbitration grant that was handed down successful 2017 pursuing a failed — and allegedly fraudulent — state deal.

That magnitude equals astir a 3rd of Nigeria’s forex reserves, and its payout would woody a immense stroke to Africa’s largest economy, which is inactive recovering from a pandemic-induced recession.

The lawsuit centers connected a 2010 woody betwixt the Nigerian authorities and P&ID, a British Virgin Islands-registered steadfast controlled by 3 little-known Irish businessmen.

The authorities agreed to supply escaped state for 20 years to a installation P&ID would physique successful speech for processed state that would beryllium utilized for energy generation. The woody would let the institution to merchantability the leftover products and the state to boost its powerfulness supply.

According to P&ID, the steadfast ne'er built the planned refinery due to the fact that the Nigerian authorities failed to pat its earthy gas. Nigeria claims that the woody came astir done bribes to erstwhile authorities officials, and that the grant should beryllium overturned.

In 2012, P&ID initiated arbitration, claiming that attempts to resoluteness the contented privately had failed.

Five years later, a closed-door arbitration tribunal successful the UK ordered the West African state to wage $6.6 cardinal to the steadfast to compensate for mislaid profits — an magnitude has since swelled to implicit $11 cardinal with interest. P&ID has nary different known assets.

Within a twelvemonth of the arbitration ruling, the hedge money VR Capital Group Ltd. took a involvement successful P&ID, which continued pressuring Nigeria to marque the payment. In 2019, the stakes roseate again erstwhile a UK justice issued an bid enforcing the award.

The trial, among the biggest successful UK past successful presumption of the magnitude of wealth involved, is scheduled to proceed until March. Nigeria volition elite a caller president connected Feb. 25.

Dirty Money

For its part, Nigeria’s authorities has alleged that P&ID bribed erstwhile medication officials to unafraid the state contract, and colluded with erstwhile authorities lawyers and officials to equine a “sham defense” erstwhile the substance landed successful court.

With a antithetic governmental enactment present successful power, Nigerian instrumentality enforcement agencies are investigating allegations of bribery surrounding the 2010 state declaration and consequent arbitration.

Nigeria alleges slope records bespeak that 4 authorities officials oregon their household members received bribes from P&ID earlier the declaration was signed, and that 1 of them has admitted to overlooking “obvious deficiencies” successful the company’s proposal.

The country’s anti-corruption bureau has besides charged the lawyer that represented the authorities during the arbitration for allegedly bribing nationalist officials progressive successful the proceedings.

In earlier hearings, P&ID denied each allegations and characterized the Nigerian government’s claims of fraud — made astir 3 years aft the arbitration ruling — arsenic an effort to dodge liability. “P&ID vigorously denies that the awards successful its favour should beryllium acceptable aside,” a spokesperson told Bloomberg.

In effect to a petition for comment, a typical of VR Capitalstated, “P&ID won its arbitral grant successful 2017, 2 years anterior to VR Capital’s acquisition of a involvement successful the company. P&ID volition beryllium providing its afloat defence astatine adjacent week’s trial, which we are assured volition debunk Nigeria’s unfounded allegations.”

A authorities spokesperson told Bloomberg, “the Federal Republic of Nigeria keenly awaits the accidental to contiguous its lawsuit earlier the High Court successful London and is assured that justness volition yet beryllium served.”

Read also: Naira falls arsenic outer reserves diminution by $3.4bn

The proceedings this week comes successful the aftermath of a London court’s determination to let the Nigerian authorities to quality the arbitration ruling.

UK precocious tribunal justice Ross Cranston said successful a 2020 ruling that helium believed determination was a beardown lawsuit to beryllium made that “the state processing declaration was procured by bribes paid to insiders arsenic portion of a larger strategy to defraud Nigeria.”

If Nigeria loses successful London, the incoming president volition person to marque the important determination of whether to re-enter colony talks with P&ID, oregon proceed claiming fraud.

The institution has said it volition question authorization to prehend the state’s overseas assets, and liability from an unresolved outgo could marque it much costly for Nigeria to rise wealth successful planetary superior markets.

The proceedings comes astatine an economically susceptible infinitesimal for Africa’s largest lipid producer. During the archetypal 11 months of past year, Nigeria’s authorities spent 80% of its income connected servicing indebtedness arsenic lipid accumulation declined and spending roseate connected substance subsidies.

The state was besides downgraded by Fitch Ratings and Moody’s Investors Service, sending its recognition ratings deeper into junk territory.

Whatever the trial’s outcome, it apt won’t beryllium last — the precocious court’s determination tin beryllium further challenged successful the UK Court of Appeal, and ultimately, the Supreme Court.