A Decade Later, Your Phone Still Can't Replace a Pro Camera - CNET

1 year ago 58

On a chilly Saturday day successful San Francisco, I was nether a patio heater with a radical of friends erstwhile idiosyncratic said we should get a radical photo. What happened adjacent was surprising. Instead of utilizing his telephone to instrumentality a commemorative photo, my person pulled retired a point-and-shoot camera. I thought to myself, "Wait. The telephone killed the point-and-shoot camera years ago. Why didn't helium conscionable usage his iPhone?" Granted it was the high-end Sony RX100 VII, which is an fantabulous compact camera and 1 of the fewer point-and-shoots inactive made today.

Phones from Apple, Samsung and Google see immoderate of the best telephone cameras you tin buy, similar the iPhone 14 Pro, Google Pixel 7 Pro and Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra. But for nonrecreational photographers and filmmakers, that's not ever enough. The beatified grail is being capable to person a genuinely ample representation sensor similar the 1 you'd find successful a high-end mirrorless camera and a lens equine that could connect to your phone. Sounds elemental capable right? Wrong.

Everyone from Samsung to Panasonic, Sony and Motorola has tried to marque this imagination a world successful immoderate way. Now Xiaomi, the world's 3rd largest phone-maker (behind Samsung and Apple) is the latest to rekindle the quest for the telephone camera beatified grail. The institution has a caller prototype telephone that lets you equine a Leica M lens connected it.

But this is conscionable a concept. If you're wondering whether phones volition ever marque dedicated pro cameras obsolete the mode they did with point-and-shoots, the reply is simply a resounding no. The past decennary has shown america why.

Why telephone cameras are limited

First, it's important to recognize however your phone's camera works. Behind the lens is simply a tiny representation sensor, smaller than a azygous Lego brick. Sometimes determination are headlines that Sony, Sharp or, years ago, Panasonic enactment a 1-inch sensor successful a phone. Sadly, that sanction doesn't notation to the existent dimensions and successful reality, a 1-inch representation sensor is astir 0.6 of an inch diagonally or, for the involvement of approximation, 2 Lego bricks. The 1-inch sensor is the hoverboard of cameras, but it's inactive 1 of the largest to beryllium enactment into a phone.

Dedicated cameras person sensors that are person to 12 Lego bricks (positioned side-by-side successful a four-by-three rectangle) and astir travel with a lens equine that lets you alteration lenses. The "holy grail" is to enactment 1 of these larger sensors into a phone.

But bigger sensors are much costly than the small ones utilized successful your iPhone and determination are abstraction considerations. A lens for a telephone camera sensor is comparatively small. But lenses for a full-frame sensor are larger and necessitate much abstraction betwixt the backmost of the lens and the sensor. Phones simply deficiency this country without becoming importantly thicker.

Every twelvemonth we spot Apple, Samsung and the similar instrumentality tiny steps toward improving telephone photography. But telephone camera hardware has mostly deed a ceiling. Instead of extremist camera improvements, we get humble upgrades. This could beryllium a motion that companies person honed successful connected what consumers want. But it could besides beryllium a effect of abstraction and size limitations of tiny sensors.

Instead smartphone-makers usage computational photography to flooded a tiny sensor's limitations -- smaller dynamic scope and airy sensitivity. Google, Apple, Samsung each usage instrumentality learning algorithms and artificial quality to amended the photos you instrumentality with your phone.

We’ve been partnering with Sony for implicit a decennary to make the world’s starring camera sensors for iPhone. Thanks to Ken and everyone connected the squad for showing maine astir the cutting-edge installation successful Kumamoto today. pic.twitter.com/462SEkUbhi

— Tim Cook (@tim_cook) December 13, 2022

But hardware is besides important. Earlier this period Tim Cook, Apple's CEO, shared a photograph connected Twitter, above, of a sojourn to Sony successful Japan. While it's been wide assumed that Apple uses Sony's representation sensors successful the iPhone, this is the archetypal clip Cook formally acknowledged it. And arsenic CNET readers already know, Sony phones similar the Xperia 1 IV person immoderate of the champion camera hardware recovered connected immoderate telephone sold today.

The Xperia 1 IV won a CNET Innovation award for its telephoto camera, which has miniature lens elements that really determination backmost and forth, similar a existent telephoto lens. The effect is that you tin usage the lens to zoom without cropping digitally, which degrades the image. Can you ideate an iPhone 15 Pro with this lens?

The Xiaomi 12S Ultra Leica lens prototype is truthful 2013

That brings america to Xiaomi, which is the latest institution attempting to merge pro-level cameras with your phone. In November, Xiaomi released a video of a telephone camera concept that shows a Leica lens mounted connected a 12S Ultra phone. This prototype is similar a conception car: No substance however chill it is, you'll ne'er get to thrust it.

The Chinese institution took the 12S Ultra and added a removable ringing astir its circular camera bump. The ringing covers a thread astir the extracurricular borderline of the camera bump onto which you tin connect an adapter that lets you equine Leica M lenses. The adapter's thickness is the aforesaid region that a Leica M lens needs to beryllium positioned distant from the sensor successful bid to focus.

A fewer caveats: The Xiaomi 12S Ultra conception uses an exposed 1-inch sensor, which arsenic I mentioned earlier, isn't really 1-inch. Next, this is purely a concept. If thing similar this really went connected sale, it would outgo thousands of dollars. A bully dedicated camera similar the Fujifilm X100 V, which has a overmuch bigger sensor, costs $1,399 successful comparison.

Xiaomi isn't the archetypal phone-maker to effort this. In 2013, Sony took an representation sensor and enactment it connected the backmost of a lens that has a grip to connect to the backmost of a phone. The thought is to usage your phone's surface arsenic the viewfinder for the camera system, which you tin power done an app. Essentially you bypass your phone's cameras.

Sony made respective antithetic versions of this "lens with a grip" and utilized sensors that were conscionable a spot bigger than those recovered successful telephone cameras. Sony besides made the QX-1 camera, which had an APS-C sized sensor that successful our Lego approximation is astir six bricks positioned side-by-side successful a three-by-two rectangle. That's not arsenic ample arsenic a full-frame sensor, but vastly bigger than your phone's representation sensors.

The Sony QX-1 has a Sony E-mount, meaning you tin usage assorted E-mount lenses oregon usage adapters for Canon oregon Nikon lenses. Because the QX-1 is controlled with Bluetooth, you could either connect it to your telephone oregon enactment it successful antithetic places to instrumentality photos remotely.

The QX-1 came retired successful 2014 and outgo $350. Imagine having thing similar this today? I would decidedly bargain a 2022 mentation if Sony made it, but sadly the QX-1 was disconitntued a fewer years aft it went connected sale. That's astir the clip that Red, the institution that makes cinema cameras utilized to movie shows and movies similar The Hobbit, The Witcher, Midsommar and The Boys, made a telephone called the Red Hydrogen One.

A Red Hydrogen One telephone is someone's hand

Despite being a telephone made by 1 of the champion camera companies successful the world, the $1,300 Red Hydrogen One's cameras were connected par with those from a $700 Android phone. The backmost of the telephone had pogo pins designed to connect antithetic modules (like Moto Mods), including a "cinema camera module" that housed a ample representation sensor and a lens mount, according to patent drawings. The thought is that you would usage a Hydrogen One and the cinema mod to crook the telephone into a mini-Red cinema camera.

Well, that ne'er happened.

The Red Hydrogen One was discontinued and present shows up arsenic a telephone prop successful films similar F9, connected the dashboard of Dominic Toretto's car oregon successful the hands of Leonard DiCaprio successful Don't Look Up.

An illustration showing a Red Hydrogen One telephone and imaginable attachments

2023 volition amusement that pro cameras won't beryllium killed disconnected by our phones

There aren't immoderate rumors that Apple is making an iPhone with a camera lens mount, nor are determination murmurs of a Google mirrorless camera. But if Xiaomi made a prototype of a telephone with a nonrecreational lens mount, you person to ideate that determination successful the basement of Apple Park sits an aged conception camera that runs an iOS-like interface, is powered by the iPhone's A-series spot and capable to usage immoderate of the aforesaid computational photography processing. Or astatine slightest that's what I'd similar to believe.

How astonishing would photos look from a pro-level dedicated camera that uses the aforesaid processing tricks that Apple oregon Google instrumentality connected their phones? And however bully would it beryllium to person a phone-like OS to stock those photos and videos to Instagram oregon TikTok?

The backmost of the Samsung Galaxy Camera

Turns out, Samsung tried bringing an Android phone's interface to a camera successful 2012. Noticing a taxable here? Most of these beatified grail telephone camera concepts were tried 10 years ago. A fewer of these, similar the Sony QX-1, were genuinely up of their time.

I don't deliberation Apple volition ever merchandise a standalone iOS-powered camera oregon marque an iPhone with a Leica lens mount. The information is that implicit the past decade, cameras person gotten smaller. The bulky dSLRs that signified nonrecreational cameras for years are rapidly heading into the sunset. Mirrorless cameras person risen successful popularity. They thin to beryllium smaller, since they don't request the abstraction for a dSLR reflector box.

If determination is simply a takeaway from each of this, it's conscionable a reminder of how bully the cameras connected our phones person gotten successful that time. Even if it feels similar they've plateaued, they're dependable for astir mundane tasks. But they won't beryllium replacing nonrecreational cameras anytime soon.

If you privation to measurement up into a nonrecreational camera, find 1 similar the Fujifilm X100 V oregon Sony A7C, that battalion a ample representation sensor, a crisp lens and tin acceptable into a overgarment pocket. And adjacent clip I'm astatine a meal enactment with friends, I won't enactment truthful shocked erstwhile idiosyncratic wants to instrumentality a representation with a camera alternatively of a phone.