Apple hit with another fine in Brazil over not selling iPhone with a charger - 9to5Mac

2 years ago 52

Back successful September, the Brazilian Ministry of Justice ordered the suspension of iPhone income successful the state aft deciding that Apple harms consumers by selling the merchandise without the powerfulness adapter. Apple has continued selling iPhones successful Brazil contempt the ban, and a Brazilian tribunal connected Tuesday fined Apple – erstwhile again – for not including the accessory successful the phone’s box.

Brazilian tribunal wants to unit Apple to vessel iPhones with a charger

This time, the determination came from a tribunal successful the authorities of São Paulo. According to the justice (via Reuters), what Apple does is simply a “tie-in sale” since determination are consumers who don’t person a compatible powerfulness adapter astatine location and are forced to bargain a caller one, which has been sold separately since 2020.

Apple, of course, claims that it nary longer ships the iPhone with the powerfulness adapter included arsenic a mode to trim c emissions and physics waste. However, the Brazilian tribunal believes that this is conscionable a mode for the institution to marque much wealth by selling its ain accessories.

As a result, Apple was fined R$100 cardinal (which is astir $19 million) by the São Paulo Court of Justice. The tribunal besides ordered Apple to see the powerfulness adapter successful iPhones sold successful Brazil. Apple has said that it volition entreaty the decision, conscionable arsenic it did erstwhile the Brazilian Ministry of Justice ordered a halt to iPhone income successful the country.

Previously, Apple had already accumulated much than R$20 cardinal (about $3.7 million) successful fines successful Brazil for not selling iPhones with a charger included. Of course, the company’s determination to entreaty the ruling buys immoderate other clip to support selling the devices successful Brazil portion it prepares its defence successful court.

It’s worthy noting that pre-orders for the iPhone 14 and iPhone 14 Pro began successful Brazil past week, with the authoritative motorboat acceptable for this Friday. At slightest for now, the phones volition vessel without a charger included.

Earlier this year, Samsung was deed with the aforesaid request successful Brazil. However, dissimilar Apple, the South Korean institution decided to beryllium compliant with the Brazilian authorities and is present including the plug adapter with its latest products, specified arsenic the Galaxy Z Flip 4 and Galaxy Z Fold 4.

USB-C whitethorn go mandatory successful Brazil

But the quality betwixt Apple and the Brazilian authorities whitethorn not halt there. The Brazilian telecom regulatory agency, besides known arsenic Anatel, has projected that every smartphone sold successful the state should follow USB-C arsenic a standard.

Unsurprisingly, this aligns with the recent European Union decision, which volition besides unit Apple to follow USB-C successful the iPhone starting successful 2024. The US Senate is besides considering a akin proposal, which means that the Lightning connector whitethorn beryllium successful its past days.

FTC: We usage income earning car affiliate links. More.