Baltimore prosecutors drop charges against Adnan Syed after receiving DNA test results - WBAL TV Baltimore

2 years ago 74

DNA trial results led Baltimore prosecutors to driblet charges against Adnan Syed.During a Zoom telephone with reporters Tuesday afternoon, Erica Suter, Syed's nationalist defender, said, "(Syed) is elated, helium is joyful, helium is inactive processing this."Syed, 41, who was released successful September aft serving 23 years successful situation for the sidesplitting of Hae Min Lee successful 1999, had his condemnation vacated by a Baltimore judge. It was recovered retired that prosecutors failed to archer Syed's defence attorneys astir grounds that would person allowed him to support himself, including details that established 2 different radical had threatened Lee's life.Early Tuesday afternoon, Baltimore City State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby said "justice implicit convictions" is the mantra of her office, and she apologized to some the Syed and Lee families."Although my medication was not liable for neither the symptom inflicted upon Hae Min Lee's household nor was my medication liable for the wrongful condemnation of Mr. Syed, arsenic a typical of the institution, it is my work to admit and to apologize to the household of Hae Min Lee and Adnan Syed," Mosby said.The authorities had a 30-day play to determine to refile the lawsuit oregon to not prosecute. "Today, justness is done, and that means today, time and until my medication ends, we volition proceed to utilize each disposable assets to find who is liable for the decease of Hae Min Lee," Mosby said. "It is my work to guarantee that justness is not delayed, justness is ne'er denied, but justness beryllium done. Today, justness is done."Mosby said her bureau connected Friday received the results of interaction DNA investigating connected items that were not tested earlier that included a skirt, pantyhose, shoes and a overgarment belonging to Lee. Mosby said determination was a DNA substance of aggregate contributors connected some shoes and that Adnan Syed's DNA was excluded.Last year, prosecutors and Syed's defence lawyer teamed up for an probe that uncovered 2 imaginable suspects successful the case. Mosby declined to merchandise much accusation Tuesday. "I deliberation you tin imagine, this has been, determination has been truthful galore ups and downs implicit the past 23 years. So, helium is truly conscionable taking it each in. He is incredibly grateful for each of the radical who person supported him and believed successful him implicit the years," Suter said.Video below: Public defender's quality league successful its entiretyMosby said that due to the fact that of advances successful DNA investigating from erstwhile the lawsuit was initially tried, they were capable to exclude Syed from the case, saying, "The lawsuit is over.""It's really interaction DNA. It analyzes tegument cells near down connected grounds astatine a transgression country and has been disposable since 2003, and this lawsuit started successful 1999," Mosby said."This is simply a wide denotation that the state's attorney's bureau does not judge they tin beryllium Adnan Syed is guilty, and successful fact, they person said they judge this is grounds of his existent innocence and this is hugely significant," said Professor David Jaros, University of Baltimore Law School module manager of the Center for Criminal Justice Reform.The nationalist defender's bureau confirmed that Syed is present disconnected location detention."Today's the time that Adnan Syed and his loved ones person been waiting for 23 agelong years. The results of the DNA investigating excluded Adnan and corroborate what Adnan and his supporters person ever known: That Adnan Syed is innocent. The authorities of Maryland has dropped the charges. Adnan Syed is free," said Suter, adjunct nationalist defender and manager of the Innocence Project Clinic astatine University of Baltimore Law School.Mosby said determination are procedural steps to spell earlier the courts, including a recertification process, earlier Syed tin beryllium considered "innocent" successful the case. Certification volition instrumentality spot arsenic soon arsenic possible, Suter said during a Tuesday day quality conference.Video below: State's attorney's quality league successful its entirety Syed household respondsAdnan Syed's brother, Yusuf Syed, said helium was blessed his member tin yet person a life, and they tin each determination on."Now, my ma is happy, and I'm happy, too, that this is done," Yusuf Syed said. "Something Mrs. Mosby said successful her property proceeding that I appreciated a batch that not galore radical cognize is that she said, for 23 years, the household has been successful prison. A batch of people, they don't recognize that it wasn't conscionable Adnan who was affected. We were each affected."Yusuf Syed said it was particularly hard connected his begetter to person his member successful prison."He was truly depressed due to the fact that him and Adnan were precise close. Adnan was his favourite child, truthful to suffer Adnan. that truly destroyed him a lot," Yusuf Syed said.Lee household lawyer respondsThere was nary nationalist announcement of the latest tribunal proceeding successful the Adnan Syed lawsuit due to the fact that prosecutors successful Baltimore City are allowed to look astatine immoderate clip without announcement to nolle prosequi. Court officials said the tribunal received an email Friday from the prosecutor, indicating that they wished to telephone the Adnan Syed substance Tuesday morning.An entreaty brought by the Lee household successful the Court of Special Appeals remains pending. The tribunal has not dismissed the entreaty arsenic of Tuesday.Mosby said she e-mailed Lee household lawyer Steve Kelly connected Monday greeting and said her bureau tried to hold for confirmation of announcement earlier releasing thing publically but person since not heard backmost from the attorney.Steve Kelly released a connection aboriginal Tuesday afternoon, saying: "We are representing Hae Min Lee's household connected a pro bono ground to enforce their rights arsenic Maryland transgression victims. The family's extremity is simply to recognize the reasons for the state's abrupt reversal of its presumption and to person a dependable connected that issue. Both the household and the nationalist merit answers that the authorities has failed to provide."After 23 years of having Hae's execution dredged up again and again, the household deserves much than an email sent to their lawyer 4 minutes aft quality of today's dismissal broke successful the media. Truly respecting victim's dependable successful the process requires acold much than that."Timeline of the caseLee and Adnan Syed were students astatine Woodlawn High School successful Baltimore County. Lee was strangled, and her assemblage was recovered buried successful Leakin Park successful Baltimore City. At the time, constabulary believed Adnan Syed killed Lee due to the fact that helium was distraught implicit their breakup. His archetypal proceedings ended successful a mistrial. A assemblage convicted him successful a 2nd trial. Adnan Syed had been successful jailhouse since his apprehension successful February 1999. In 2000, a assemblage recovered Adnan Syed blameworthy of murder. Prosecutors relied heavy connected cellphone information and the grounds of a person of Adnan Syed's, who said helium helped him hide the body. In 2014, the podcast "Serial" debuted and raised doubts astir the case, explaining that a girl, Asia McClain, said she was with Adnan Syed successful the room astatine the clip erstwhile constabulary said Lee was killed.It was learned that Adnan Syed's lawyer knew astir the imaginable alibi but did not telephone McClain to testify. That lawyer was aboriginal disbarred aft a bid of complaints involving galore cases."With greater media attention, it brings a airy to injustices that are commonplace. So, what has happened to Adnan is tragic and horrible but it is incredibly common," Suter said. "This benignant of usurpation is not unusual."Between 2015 and 2019, determination was overmuch back-and-forth procedural developments successful court. A justice granted Adnan Syed a caller trial, and, aft a bid of appeals, the Maryland Court of Appeals denied the trial.In March 2022, prosecutors agreed to caller DNA investigating due to the fact that of advances successful familial profiling.Last month, the Baltimore City State's Attorney's Office filed a question to vacate the conviction, saying it uncovered the imaginable engagement of 2 "alternative suspects." The question besides admits the lawsuit was ruled mostly connected circumstantial evidence, and prosecutors said they lacked assurance "in the integrity of the conviction."What's adjacent for Adnan Syed?Adnan Syed is astatine location spending clip with his family, and he's asking for privateness arsenic helium processes Tuesday's announcement and begins to heal.WBAL-TV spoke with his attorney, who said Adnan Syed is mounting his sights connected the future.Adnan Syed's attorney, Erica Suter, said this is the time helium and his household person been waiting for. He is elated. He's joyful, but with truthful galore ups and downs implicit the past 23 years. Now, he's conscionable trying to instrumentality it each in.Suter said Adnan Syed is conscionable spending clip with his household doing the mundane small things, the freedoms galore of america instrumentality for granted. She said Adnan Syed is incredibly grateful for each of the radical who person supported him and believed successful him implicit the years, including his member Yusuf Syed."We've been capable to hug him to person him successful our location to speech to him to spot him close successful beforehand of us," Yusuf Syed said.As for what's next, Suter said Adnan Syed wants to proceed his acquisition astatine Georgetown University, thing helium started down bars."I cognize that he's precise committed. He was lone 17 erstwhile helium was incarcerated. He was accepted to college. He was truly astatine the precipice of his young beingness and I deliberation helium wants to implicit that and gain his degree," Suter said.Once he's earns that degree, Suter said Adnan Syed wants to spell to instrumentality school. Suter besides said, similar each of us, Adnan Syed wants to cognize what happened to Lee and to spot her existent slayer brought to justice."Because Adnan is guiltless and didn't person immoderate relation successful this, I deliberation helium wants to cognize similar the remainder of america what truly happened," Suter said.When asked whether Adnan Syed would question compensation for his wrongful conviction, Suter said that's a question for different day.

BALTIMORE —

DNA trial results led Baltimore prosecutors to driblet charges against Adnan Syed.

During a Zoom telephone with reporters Tuesday afternoon, Erica Suter, Syed's nationalist defender, said, "(Syed) is elated, helium is joyful, helium is inactive processing this."

Syed, 41, who was released successful September aft serving 23 years successful situation for the sidesplitting of Hae Min Lee successful 1999, had his conviction vacated by a Baltimore judge. It was recovered retired that prosecutors failed to archer Syed's defence attorneys astir grounds that would person allowed him to support himself, including details that established 2 different radical had threatened Lee's life.

Early Tuesday afternoon, Baltimore City State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby said "justice implicit convictions" is the mantra of her office, and she apologized to some the Syed and Lee families.

"Although my medication was not liable for neither the symptom inflicted upon Hae Min Lee's household nor was my medication liable for the wrongful condemnation of Mr. Syed, arsenic a typical of the institution, it is my work to admit and to apologize to the household of Hae Min Lee and Adnan Syed," Mosby said.

The authorities had a 30-day play to determine to refile the lawsuit oregon to not prosecute.

"Today, justness is done, and that means today, time and until my medication ends, we volition proceed to utilize each disposable assets to find who is liable for the decease of Hae Min Lee," Mosby said. "It is my work to guarantee that justness is not delayed, justness is ne'er denied, but justness beryllium done. Today, justness is done."

Mosby said her bureau connected Friday received the results of interaction DNA investigating connected items that were not tested earlier that included a skirt, pantyhose, shoes and a overgarment belonging to Lee. Mosby said determination was a DNA substance of aggregate contributors connected some shoes and that Adnan Syed's DNA was excluded.

Last year, prosecutors and Syed's defence lawyer teamed up for an probe that uncovered 2 imaginable suspects successful the case. Mosby declined to merchandise much accusation Tuesday.

"I deliberation you tin imagine, this has been, determination has been truthful galore ups and downs implicit the past 23 years. So, helium is truly conscionable taking it each in. He is incredibly grateful for each of the radical who person supported him and believed successful him implicit the years," Suter said.

Video below: Public defender's news league successful its entirety

Mosby said that due to the fact that of advances successful DNA investigating from erstwhile the lawsuit was initially tried, they were capable to exclude Syed from the case, saying, "The lawsuit is over."

"It's really interaction DNA. It analyzes tegument cells near down connected grounds astatine a transgression country and has been disposable since 2003, and this lawsuit started successful 1999," Mosby said.

"This is simply a wide denotation that the state's attorney's bureau does not judge they tin beryllium Adnan Syed is guilty, and successful fact, they person said they judge this is grounds of his existent innocence and this is hugely significant," said Professor David Jaros, University of Baltimore Law School module manager of the Center for Criminal Justice Reform.

The nationalist defender's bureau confirmed that Syed is present disconnected location detention.

"Today's the time that Adnan Syed and his loved ones person been waiting for 23 agelong years. The results of the DNA investigating excluded Adnan and corroborate what Adnan and his supporters person ever known: That Adnan Syed is innocent. The authorities of Maryland has dropped the charges. Adnan Syed is free," said Suter, adjunct nationalist defender and manager of the Innocence Project Clinic astatine University of Baltimore Law School.

Mosby said determination are procedural steps to spell earlier the courts, including a recertification process, earlier Syed tin beryllium considered "innocent" successful the case. Certification volition instrumentality spot arsenic soon arsenic possible, Suter said during a Tuesday day quality conference.

Video below: State's attorney's quality league successful its entirety

Syed household responds

Adnan Syed's brother, Yusuf Syed, said helium was blessed his member tin yet person a life, and they tin each determination on.

"Now, my ma is happy, and I'm happy, too, that this is done," Yusuf Syed said. "Something Mrs. Mosby said successful her property proceeding that I appreciated a batch that not galore radical cognize is that she said, for 23 years, the household has been successful prison. A batch of people, they don't recognize that it wasn't conscionable Adnan who was affected. We were each affected."

Yusuf Syed said it was particularly hard connected his begetter to person his member successful prison.

"He was truly depressed due to the fact that him and Adnan were precise close. Adnan was his favourite child, truthful to suffer Adnan. that truly destroyed him a lot," Yusuf Syed said.

Lee household lawyer responds

There was nary nationalist announcement of the latest tribunal proceeding successful the Adnan Syed lawsuit due to the fact that prosecutors successful Baltimore City are allowed to look astatine immoderate clip without announcement to nolle prosequi. Court officials said the tribunal received an email Friday from the prosecutor, indicating that they wished to telephone the Adnan Syed substance Tuesday morning.

An appeal brought by the Lee family successful the Court of Special Appeals remains pending. The tribunal has not dismissed the entreaty arsenic of Tuesday.

Mosby said she e-mailed Lee household lawyer Steve Kelly connected Monday greeting and said her bureau tried to hold for confirmation of announcement earlier releasing thing publically but person since not heard backmost from the attorney.

Steve Kelly released a connection aboriginal Tuesday afternoon, saying: "We are representing Hae Min Lee's household connected a pro bono ground to enforce their rights arsenic Maryland transgression victims. The family's extremity is simply to recognize the reasons for the state's abrupt reversal of its presumption and to person a dependable connected that issue. Both the household and the nationalist merit answers that the authorities has failed to provide.

"After 23 years of having Hae's execution dredged up again and again, the household deserves much than an email sent to their lawyer 4 minutes aft quality of today's dismissal broke successful the media. Truly respecting victim's dependable successful the process requires acold much than that."

Timeline of the case

Lee and Adnan Syed were students astatine Woodlawn High School successful Baltimore County. Lee was strangled, and her assemblage was recovered buried successful Leakin Park successful Baltimore City. At the time, constabulary believed Adnan Syed killed Lee due to the fact that helium was distraught implicit their breakup.

His archetypal proceedings ended successful a mistrial. A assemblage convicted him successful a 2nd trial. Adnan Syed had been successful jailhouse since his apprehension successful February 1999. In 2000, a assemblage recovered Adnan Syed blameworthy of murder. Prosecutors relied heavy connected cellphone information and the grounds of a person of Adnan Syed's, who said helium helped him hide the body.

In 2014, the podcast "Serial" debuted and raised doubts astir the case, explaining that a girl, Asia McClain, said she was with Adnan Syed successful the room astatine the clip erstwhile constabulary said Lee was killed.

It was learned that Adnan Syed's lawyer knew astir the imaginable alibi but did not telephone McClain to testify. That lawyer was aboriginal disbarred aft a bid of complaints involving galore cases.

"With greater media attention, it brings a airy to injustices that are commonplace. So, what has happened to Adnan is tragic and horrible but it is incredibly common," Suter said. "This benignant of usurpation is not unusual."

Between 2015 and 2019, determination was overmuch back-and-forth procedural developments successful court. A justice granted Adnan Syed a caller trial, and, aft a bid of appeals, the Maryland Court of Appeals denied the trial.

In March 2022, prosecutors agreed to caller DNA investigating due to the fact that of advances successful familial profiling.

Last month, the Baltimore City State's Attorney's Office filed a question to vacate the conviction, saying it uncovered the imaginable engagement of 2 "alternative suspects." The question besides admits the lawsuit was ruled mostly connected circumstantial evidence, and prosecutors said they lacked assurance "in the integrity of the conviction."

What's adjacent for Adnan Syed?

Adnan Syed is astatine location spending clip with his family, and he's asking for privateness arsenic helium processes Tuesday's announcement and begins to heal.

WBAL-TV spoke with his attorney, who said Adnan Syed is mounting his sights connected the future.

Adnan Syed's attorney, Erica Suter, said this is the time helium and his household person been waiting for. He is elated. He's joyful, but with truthful galore ups and downs implicit the past 23 years. Now, he's conscionable trying to instrumentality it each in.

Suter said Adnan Syed is conscionable spending clip with his household doing the mundane small things, the freedoms galore of america instrumentality for granted. She said Adnan Syed is incredibly grateful for each of the radical who person supported him and believed successful him implicit the years, including his member Yusuf Syed.

"We've been capable to hug him to person him successful our location to speech to him to spot him close successful beforehand of us," Yusuf Syed said.

As for what's next, Suter said Adnan Syed wants to proceed his acquisition astatine Georgetown University, thing helium started down bars.

"I cognize that he's precise committed. He was lone 17 erstwhile helium was incarcerated. He was accepted to college. He was truly astatine the precipice of his young beingness and I deliberation helium wants to implicit that and gain his degree," Suter said.

Once he's earns that degree, Suter said Adnan Syed wants to spell to instrumentality school. Suter besides said, similar each of us, Adnan Syed wants to cognize what happened to Lee and to spot her existent slayer brought to justice.

"Because Adnan is guiltless and didn't person immoderate relation successful this, I deliberation helium wants to cognize similar the remainder of america what truly happened," Suter said.

When asked whether Adnan Syed would question compensation for his wrongful conviction, Suter said that's a question for different day.

Read Entire Article