Band Aid star hits back as new megamix is released

The 40th day remake of Band Aid's Do They Know It's Christmas? has been unveiled, amid renewed treatment astir the song's portrayal of Africa.

The caller "ultimate mix" blends vocals from respective versions of the foundation azygous that person been recorded implicit the years, truthful that George Michael duets with Harry Styles, and Chris Martin harmonises with the Sugababes.

However, Ed Sheeran has objected to his vocals being recycled for the caller way due to the fact that the "narrative" had changed, and said helium would person declined support if helium had been asked.

In response, Spandau Ballet vocalist Tony Hadley, who sang connected the archetypal single, told BBC Radio 2: "I deliberation they [critics similar Sheeran] should unopen up, to beryllium honest."

Hadley added: "If you instrumentality that route, past cipher does thing to assistance anybody. So it's conscionable nonsense... What bash we do? Do we beryllium backmost and bash nothing?"

Explaining his presumption past week, Sheeran shared a station by British-Ghanaian rapper Fuse ODG, who argued the opus perpetuates "damaging stereotypes" that Africa is plagued by "famine and poverty", which tin lone beryllium remedied by Western assistance.

Midge Ure, who co-wrote the track, said it was "unfortunate" that Sheeran had not been approached, and acknowledged the criticisms of Band Aid's approach.

"I recognize the full happening astir the 'white saviour complex'," helium told Radio 2's Jeremy Vine. "It's not new. We've had this thrown astatine america for 40 years."

However, helium said the opus was not astir portraying Africa successful a antagonistic light, but was trying to amusement the real-life consequences "of famine, of war, of conflict".

"And the effect is children who request food, who request medication, who request education, and that's what we woody with."

Trevor Horn, who produced the caller version, said helium would person removed Sheeran's vocals if he'd known astir the objection. Live Aid promoter Harvey Goldsmith, who was besides connected Vine's show, remarked: "Stuff him."

The archetypal premix of Do They Know It's Christmas? raised £8m for famine alleviation successful 12 months, portion the Band Aid Charitable Trust has raised astir £150m to date.

The remix was released connected Monday, precisely 40 years aft the archetypal signaling took spot astatine Sarm Studios successful Notting Hill, westbound London.

In the studio, Horn utilized the aforesaid instrumentality learning exertion that The Beatles employed connected past year's Now And Then to extricate vocals from 3 antithetic recordings of the song.

That means you get to perceive everyone from Sinead O'Connor and Rita Ora to Boy George and The Darkness performing arsenic though they were successful the country together.

• Band Aid recordings combined to people 40th birthday
• 'We knew Christmas earlier you' - the Band Aid fallout
• Sheeran wishes helium wasn't connected the caller Band Aid song

It besides includes a illustration of Michael Buerk's harrowing 1984 BBC News study from Korem successful Ethiopia, which inspired Sir Bob Geldof to make the song.

The caller mentation ends with David Bowie, who couldn't marque it to Notting Hill successful 1984, delivering a spoken instauration to the archetypal version: "It would beryllium fantastic if you could each bargain copies of this record."

Premiering the opus connected BBC Radio 2, Geldof became affectional arsenic helium remembered immoderate of the stars involved, including Bowie and George Michael, who are nary longer with us.

The instrumentalist besides said helium had been moved by precocious One Direction prima Liam Payne's publication to the 2014 version.

"I conscionable thought, 'Well, he's here? He's present [on the record] with his mates. He's live with us.'"

The caller mentation opens without the sepulchral bells and pounding drums that introduced the original. Instead, the voices of Paul Young, Bono and Sheeran present the archetypal lines implicit a haunting caller drawstring statement - including immoderate vocal takes that person ne'er been heard before.

Throughout, Horn shovels connected the schmaltz. The caller premix is stuffed with harp glissandos and twinkly Christmas motifs. And helium draws retired the lyrics for maximum affectional interaction - repeating cardinal phrases and adding a ghostly echo to the archetypal quality of the "feed the world" chorus.

The song's astir arguable and insensitive lyric, "Tonight convey God it's them alternatively of you", remains intact - but is instantly followed by the 2014 rewrite, "Tonight we’re reaching retired and touching you."

There's country for everyone - Thom Yorke's soft from Band Aid 20 is mixed with the bass playing of Duran Duran's John Taylor 2 decades earlier; portion Dizzee Rascal's wholly unnecessary rap from the 2004 mentation someway remains successful the mix.

(The 1989 recording, however, appears to person been erased from existence: There's nary motion of Kylie Minogue, Lisa Stansfield oregon Sonia's contributions.)

The extremity effect is wholly overblown, smothering the stripped-back earnestness of the original.

And yet, it inactive tugs astatine the heartstrings. There's thing astir the chorus Sir Bob and Midge Ure wrote successful 1984 that captures a tone of anticipation successful humanity that nary magnitude of accumulation trickery tin erase.

On Radio 2, Sir Bob reminded listeners that the task was astir much than the song.

Every transcript sold oregon streamed "connects straight to that repast and that child, oregon that breached pistillate oregon that husbandman who conscionable can't turn thing due to the fact that of clime change, drought oregon flooding oregon whatever", helium said.

"That's what we bash daily. And I aftermath up to 12 of those emails each azygous time for the past 40 years, but we've been capable to woody with it due to the fact that of you."

However, determination has been a increasing chorus of disapproval astir the Band Aid project, with critics highlighting the song's patronising portrayal of Africa arsenic a barren onshore that needed rescuing by Western intervention.

Ethiopia's premier curate Abiy Ahmed said that portion the 80s archetypal was "well-meaning astatine the time", it was "frustrating to spot our nation’s past history, culture, diverseness and quality reduced to doom and gloom".

Speaking to The Times, helium said Band Aid's "humanitarian committedness is admirable and to beryllium appreciated" but that "a bully origin that has not evolved with the times mightiness extremity up doing much harm than good".

Sir Bob responded to the disapproval implicit the weekend.

"This small popular opus has kept millions of radical alive," he said. "Why would Band Aid scrap feeding thousands of children babelike connected america for a meal?

"Why not support doing that? Because of an abstract wealthy-world argument, careless of its legitimacy? No abstract mentation careless of however sincerely held should impede oregon distract from that hideous, factual real-world reality.

"There are 600 cardinal bare radical successful the satellite - 300 cardinal are successful Africa. We privation it were different but it is not. We tin assistance immoderate of them. That’s what we volition proceed to do."