Calais migrants: French rescuers failed to help sinking boat

There's increasing grounds that French rescue services failed to respond adequately to a migrant vessel that sank successful the Channel past November, with astatine slightest 33 radical connected board.

Only 2 of the passengers survived the disaster.

Transcripts of exigency calls made to the French coastguard, seen by the BBC, suggest that hopeless passengers were repeatedly told to telephone UK exigency services, contempt being successful French waters erstwhile they archetypal requested help.

And a French constabulary investigation, leaked to the paper Le Monde, appears to suggest that the French coastguard ne'er sent assistance to the scene, contempt a circumstantial UK petition to bash so.

The BBC besides heard grounds that different migrant vessel was passed backmost and distant betwixt the 2 nations' rescue centres, conscionable a fewer days earlier the Channel disaster.

One twelvemonth on, the grey waters of the Channel inactive clasp galore secrets.

Beneath the cliffs astatine Cap Gris-Nez, the waves proceed to slosh against the rocks; the coastline worn to a good point, jutting retired into the sea.

It's from this clifftop that the French coastguard show the Channel for boats successful distress, and nonstop rescuers to help.

At 01:48 connected 24 November past year, according to documents seen by the BBC, operators successful the power country astatine Cap Gris-Nez received the archetypal telephone from the stricken migrant boat.

The passengers were asked to nonstop their nonstop determination from their mobile phones. When it arrived, immoderate 15 minutes later, it positioned the vessel much than fractional a mile wrong French waters.

French operators alerted the UK coastguard successful Dover, according to the documents. Twenty minutes later, aft receiving an updated determination from the boat, they sent Dover the co-ordinates, saying it was present successful British waters.

Shortly afterwards, the UK sent a connection saying the dial tones of mobile phones connected the vessel appeared to find it successful France.

But French operators continued - for much than 2 hours - to impulse passengers to telephone the UK for help, documents suggest, adjacent erstwhile a French patrol reported that the vessel was inactive successful French waters.

The newspaper, Le Monde, quoting a leaked French constabulary report, says the UK authorities sent a rescue vas to the country - but that they besides asked France to nonstop its patrol boat, Le Flamant, due to the fact that it was closer.

Le Flamant was ne'er sent, the insubstantial says.

The UK's Maritime Accident Investigation Branch, which is starring the British inquiry, confirmed successful an interim study that immoderate of the events starring to the catastrophe did instrumentality spot successful British waters.

It said the Dover power country "dispatched UK aboveground and aerial assets to hunt the country wherever the distressed migrants were assessed to be. However, thing was found".

One relationship of grounds from a French relation connected work that night, seen by the BBC, says that Le Flamant was already helping different vessel successful difficulty. Le Monde says the constabulary study disputes this.

Transcripts of conversations from the nighttime amusement French operators repeatedly assuring those clinging to the sinking wreckage that assistance was connected its way, arsenic passengers screamed successful the background.

In 1 exchange, an relation appears to mock the caller aft the enactment is cut, saying, "Oh well, you can't perceive me, you won't beryllium saved. 'My feet are successful the water' - I didn't inquire you to leave."

Material seen by the BBC besides suggests that different vessel passing adjacent to the country that nighttime was turned distant by French operators, aft it offered to intervene.

The 2 survivors were yet rescued by a sportfishing vas the pursuing afternoon.

"If these radical were successful French waters and if astatine immoderate infinitesimal determination was negligence, an error, determination volition beryllium sanctions," France's Minister for the Sea, Hervé Berville, told parliament.

The BBC requested an interrogation with Mr Berville past week. His squad refused the petition and refused to springiness a comment, alternatively referring the BBC to the minister's comments successful parliament and adding that determination is an "ongoing investigation" into the incident.

The BBC past made a petition for an interrogation with the French Interior Minister Gérald Darmanin. His squad did not respond.

But sources wrong the French judiciary person told the BBC they are presently considering whether to absorption the probe much intimately connected the relation of French rescue services.

Maria Thomas, a UK lawyer representing 1 subsister and much than a twelve victims' families, says determination is simply a deficiency of urgency oregon answers from the British side. "The families privation a afloat nationalist inquiry, with afloat transparency," she told us.

"We person concerns astir the adequacy of the hunt and rescue cognition carried retired erstwhile [UK] borderline unit assets were deployed, some successful presumption of the hunt patterns utilized and connection with the boat."

The question of who should instrumentality the pb successful rescue operations successful the Channel depends to immoderate grade connected wherever the incidental takes place, but besides wherever the archetypal distress telephone is made from, and which nation's resources are champion placed to assist.

Those resources are progressively stretched, arsenic the fig of tiny vessel crossings rise. Rescue teams connected some sides of the Channel tin beryllium called to prevention hundreds of lives successful a azygous night. Some successful France had warned this was a catastrophe waiting to happen.

But the evident passing of work crossed the Channel was not unsocial to this tragedy, the BBC has learned.

Another boat, afloat of radical trying to transverse to the UK, recovered itself successful a akin presumption conscionable 4 days earlier the calamity past year.

Audio messages sent to a migrant helpline successful Dunkirk connected 20 November picture stranded passengers struggling to get help.

"We've called each the numbers," the caller says. "When I telephone 999, they accidental to telephone France; and the French accidental telephone to United Kingdom. And some of them are laughing astatine us."

And later: "Sir, we are inactive waiting and nary 1 is coming. Really frightened that nary 1 is coming. Please, effort to nonstop someone."

The BBC approached the UK and French coastguards for remark astir these allegations too. A Maritime and Coastguard Agency spokesperson said the coastguard's cardinal relation was to "save lives astatine oversea by responding to immoderate idiosyncratic successful distress".

Rafael Cuzin was the call-handler connected work that time astatine the helpline, tally by the foundation Utopia56.

"The determination of the vessel was truly adjacent to the UK waters," helium said. "I called the French coastguard. They said that the UK coastguard had fto the vessel drift into French waters."

A French lifeboat was sent to rescue them. "[But] it could person ended badly," says Rafael. "That concern truly echoed what happened connected 24th."

Zana Mamand Mohammad's member Twana was 1 of those who ne'er returned from the Channel. Last week, Zana retraced his brother's travel from Iraqi Kurdistan to France, to attest successful the probe here.

"I told him a 100 times: your beingness is much important than thing else," Zana told me. "These radical were not seen arsenic quality beings."

"You tin spot [from the transcripts] however atrocious it is," said Zana's lawyer Thomas Ricard.

"We request to recognize precisely however this articulation betwixt the 2 coastguards functions: whether determination is simply a logistical issue, whether determination is simply a resources issue, whether determination is simply a quality broadside of things. If anyone is liable, that needs to beryllium investigated."

Twana's assemblage has ne'er been found; different portion of this communicative held by the waters of the Channel.

In the twelvemonth since the calamity immoderate 40,000 radical person crossed from France to the UK successful tiny boats; the waters inactive thigh astatine the French coastline beneath Cap Gris-Nez, whispering their fickle committedness to transportation tiny boats from enactment to shore.

What are your questions astir tiny vessel migrants and the asylum cases backlog? Email your questions to YourQuestions@bbc.co.uk

You tin besides nonstop your questions successful the pursuing ways:

If you are speechmaking this leafage and can't spot the signifier you volition request to sojourn the mobile mentation of the BBC website to taxable your question oregon remark oregon you tin email america astatine YourQuestions@bbc.co.uk. Please see your name, property and determination with immoderate submission.