Carsley and the British national anthem - explained

Lee Carsley's mentation of wherefore helium volition not sing the British nationalist anthem earlier his archetypal lucifer successful complaint arsenic England's interim manager has provoked debate.

The 50-year-old, who was calved successful England but earned 40 caps for the Republic of Ireland during his playing career, was placed successful impermanent charge of the Three Lions successful August pursuing Gareth Southgate's resignation.

Carsley's tenure arsenic interim manager begins against the state helium represented arsenic a subordinate erstwhile England look the Republic of Ireland successful Dublin successful the Nations League connected Saturday.

The erstwhile Everton midfielder says helium did not sing the Irish nationalist anthem arsenic a subordinate oregon the British nationalist anthem erstwhile helium was successful complaint of England U21s due to the fact that helium was focused connected the lucifer ahead.

"This is thing that I ever struggled with erstwhile I was playing for Ireland," said Carsley.

"The spread betwixt your warm-up, your coming connected to the transportation and the hold with the anthems. So it's thing that I person ne'er done.

"I was ever truly focused connected the crippled and my archetypal actions of the game. I truly recovered that successful that play I was wary astir my caput wandering off.

"I was truly focused connected the shot and I person taken that into coaching. We had the nationalist anthem with the Under-21s besides and I americium successful a portion astatine that point. I americium reasoning astir however the absorption are going to acceptable up and our archetypal actions wrong the game.

"I afloat respect some anthems and recognize however overmuch they mean to some countries. It's thing I americium truly respectful of."

At Euro 2024, each 1 of England's starting XI passim the tourney sang God Save the King.

However, this has not ever been the case.

In 2022, Liverpool's Trent Alexander-Arnold was criticised by immoderate for failing to sing the nationalist anthem earlier a Nations League decision by Hungary successful Budapest.

Former England skipper Wayne Rooney often did not sing the nationalist anthem, peculiarly earlier helium was fixed the armband.

The Football Association backed Rooney's decision.

"Whether a subordinate wishes to sing the nationalist anthem oregon not is purely a idiosyncratic choice," an FA spokesperson said successful 2012.

But erstwhile Manchester United skipper Gary Neville says helium chose not to sing the nationalist anthem due to the fact that helium was told he "must" sing it by erstwhile FA president Geoff Thompson successful 1995. , external

"I didn't sing it the archetypal clip I played for England," said Neville.

"Partly due to the fact that I thought, I'm superior astir my enactment and I'm not singing earlier a game.

"He [Thompson] lone ever sought retired 1 speech with me.

"Did helium privation to prime my brains connected World Cup preparation? Or inquire however the FA could assistance down the scenes? No, Mr Thompson wanted to cognize wherefore I didn't sing the National Anthem.

"I'm not being told by immoderate suits what to do."

Southgate, Carsley's predecessor, was a passionate vocalist of the nationalist anthem some arsenic a subordinate and arsenic a manager.

Previously, Roy Hodgson and Sam Allardyce some sang God Save the Queen.

Sven-Goran Eriksson, from Sweden, said helium ne'er genuinely "mastered" the nationalist anthem but helium did effort to sing it earlier matches during his clip successful complaint of the Three Lions.

"I'm not definite I ever wholly mastered God Save the Queen but determination I was, a Swede, lasting successful beforehand of the seat and trying to sing it a bit," helium said.

However, Fabio Capello - who spent 5 years arsenic England brag - opted against singing the nationalist anthem arsenic the Italian said it was "wrong" to sing different nation's anthem.

"I won't sing the nationalist anthem due to the fact that I consciousness it is incorrect to sing different country's anthem,” said Capello.

“I bash get goosebumps erstwhile I perceive it though.”

National anthems successful shot and rugby are traditionally played earlier matches, erstwhile singing the nationalist anthem tin beryllium utilized by immoderate athletes to get pumped up pre-match. It is besides an accidental to sing with supporters.

In different sports specified arsenic Formula 1 oregon athletics, nationalist anthems are reserved for being played aft a triumph - which tin often beryllium a clip of reflection for sportspeople.

Lewis Hamilton, who erstwhile said the British nationalist anthem was "too short", does not sing God Save the King connected the podium aft Grand Prix races.

Similarly, Kelly Hodgkinson was successful tears and did not sing during her medal ceremonial aft winning golden successful the 800m astatine the Paris Games.

Former England cricket skipper Eoin Morgan decided against singing the nationalist anthem.

Morgan was calved successful Dublin and played for Ireland earlier switching to correspond England successful 2009.

Asked wherefore helium didn't sing God Save the Queen astatine the 2015 World Cup, Morgan said: "It's a agelong story. It's a idiosyncratic thing."

For some, the nationalist anthem is simply a awesome of pridefulness and patriotism.

The determination not to sing it, therefore, tin beryllium seen arsenic disrespectful.

However, others spot whether oregon not to sing the nationalist anthem arsenic a idiosyncratic choice.

Like Carsley, immoderate radical similar to absorption connected the upcoming lawsuit and privation to stay "in the zone".

Others, similar Neville, consciousness they should not beryllium pressurised into singing the anthem.