Chest pads for sports: Do they protect against cardiac arrest? - NBC News

Sports medicine specializer Dr. Kody Moffatt knows however seeing Damar Hamlin illness successful cardiac apprehension connected "Monday Night Football" has frightened parents of young athletes.

"Almost each household that I've seen successful session since Tuesday greeting has asked astir this," said Moffatt, part main of sports medicine astatine Children’s Hospital & Medical Center successful Omaha, Nebraska. "They were disquieted astir thorax impacts."

Such life-threatening injuries are highly rare, and though it present appears that the 24-year-old Buffalo Bills safety is recovering, the incidental was a gut punch reminder of however rapidly injuries tin happen.

Doctors astatine the University of Cincinnati Medical Center haven't announced what precisely caused Hamlin's cardiac apprehension — the abrupt nonaccomplishment of bosom relation — but during a quality briefing Thursday they didn't regularisation retired a improvement called commotio cordis.

Commotio cordis happens erstwhile a projectile — often a hockey puck oregon a baseball, for illustration — collides with a person's chest, throwing the heart's electrical strategy retired of whack. The idiosyncratic goes into perchance deadly cardiac arrest.

Immediate CPR and an automated outer defibrillator (AED) are captious successful the moments that follow, and that is however Damar Hamlin survived, experts said.

"The accelerated effect is what saved this player's life," said Dr. William Roberts, a sports medicine specializer astatine the University of Minnesota.

Commotio cordis occurs little than a fewer twelve times a year in the U.S. Could thorax protectors forestall the problem? With the pads costing up to $100 oregon more, are they worthy it?

"When it's your child, it's not rare," said Karen Acompora, committee seat for Parent Heart Watch, a radical that advocates for greater cardiac protections successful younker sports.

Louis Acompora died astatine property 14 pursuing commotio cordis during a lacrosse game.Courtesy Karen Acompora

Acompora's son, Louis, was playing successful his archetypal precocious schoolhouse lacrosse crippled connected New York's Long Island successful 2000 erstwhile a stroke to his thorax resulted successful commotio cordis. CPR was administered, but determination were nary AEDs connected site.

Louis was lone 14 erstwhile helium died. His parent has been pushing for thorax extortion successful younker sports ever since.

"I don't recognize wherefore younker sports don't leap each implicit information earlier a problem" occurs, Acompora said.

It wasn't until 2019 that the National Operating Committee connected Standards for Athletic Equipment, developed standards for thorax protectors.

In 2022, USA Lacrosse mandated that each younker lacrosse players deterioration thorax protection.

Though doctors person not said whether Hamlin's wounded was so commotio cordis, Acompora is gladsome to spot the information getting nationalist attention.

"I'm hoping with this latest incidental that radical volition unfastened their eyes and say, hmm, possibly we request to bash something."

There are mixed opinions astir thorax extortion successful younker sports.

A 2017 study led by Tufts Medical Center successful Boston recovered that thorax protectors, specifically ones that incorporated Kevlar, whitethorn "be effectual successful the prevention of commotio cordis connected the playing field."

Stephens, who was not progressive successful the Tufts study, explained that Kevlar works by spreading the vigor of an impact, alternatively than allowing a projectile to absorption each its unit successful 1 spot.

But the survey was conducted utilizing pigs, not humans. That's not capable technological grounds to backmost utilizing thorax protectors successful younker sports, said Dr. Matthew Silvis, manager of sports medicine astatine Penn State Health.

Silvis was acrophobic that a thorax protector could springiness a mendacious consciousness of security.

"What you wouldn't privation is idiosyncratic who's wearing a thorax protector to think, good I'm protected from this injury, and present I tin play a small spot much reckless," Silvis said.

Until Monday night's NFL game, Dr. Chad Stephens, an interventional symptom and sports medicine specializer successful backstage signifier adjacent Dallas, had encouraged thorax pads lone for precocious schoolhouse sports specified arsenic shot and lacrosse, successful which commotio cordis is much common.

Chest protectors specified arsenic this 1 from Unequal Technologies person been successful request since Damar Hamlin’s cardiac apprehension Monday.Courtesy Unequal Technologies

"I was not an advocator for players to person a thorax pad for non-projectile sports," Stephens said. "I wasn't arsenic convinced that thing similar that could happen" successful football. This is making maine rethink my full stance."

Rob Vito, main enforcement serviceman and laminitis of Unequal Technologies said his telephone has been ringing nonstop with calls from coaches, players and parents.

The institution makes thorax pads that see Kevlar, the aforesaid worldly utilized successful bulletproof vests.

"We're getting calls from shot moms and shot dads," said Vito. "Every athletics is reaching out."

Can commotio cordis beryllium prevented?

Instead of investing successful thorax extortion equipment, Penn State Health's Silvis advises coaches to thatch their young players due method erstwhile faced with an oncoming shot oregon hockey puck.

Players should larn to crook their assemblage arsenic overmuch arsenic imaginable to the broadside successful these cases, with the extremity of avoiding a collision to the chest.

The champion mode to prevention kids from dying from cardiac apprehension connected the playing tract is to marque definite coaches and players cognize CPR, and to person speedy entree to AEDs, said the University of Minnesota's Roberts.

"If we're looking astatine the hazard simplification of adding a thorax plate, compared to the hazard simplification of grooming everybody successful hands-only CPR having an AED disposable astatine sites, it would autumn heavy connected CPR and AEDs successful presumption of lives saved," said Roberts, who is affiliated with the National Academy of Sports Medicine.

Rather than parents buying a thorax protector, "how bash we marque definite our coaches and radical that are astatine these games are CPR trained?'" Silvis asked.

There was wide statement that AEDs are indispensable astatine each sporting events — not lone for players but besides for coaches, parents, grandparents and others watching the games.

Despite a deficiency of information showing thorax protectors ever support against commotio cordis, young athletes progressive successful baseball, hockey and lacrosse whitethorn privation to see them, Moffatt said.

"There's small harm and surely determination could beryllium important benefit," Moffatt said. "As a dada arsenic good arsenic a doctor, I similar to bash things to support my kids."

Follow NBC HEALTH on Twitter & Facebook.