Concussion protocols are based on research of mostly men. What about women? - NPR

Eugenie Bouchard, of Canada, fell astatine the installation hosting the 2015 U.S. Open tennis tourney and suffered a concussion. Charles Krupa/AP hide caption

toggle caption

Charles Krupa/AP

Eugenie Bouchard, of Canada, fell astatine the installation hosting the 2015 U.S. Open tennis tourney and suffered a concussion.

Charles Krupa/AP

Lindsay Simpson inactive has questions astir her concussions.

Her archetypal 1 came erstwhile she was 16. At the time, she was playing for a nine shot squad successful Atlanta, arsenic a promising precocious schoolhouse goalkeeper with aspirations of a Division I assistance and – successful her biggest dreams – a nonrecreational playing career.

"I dove for the ball, and my assemblage deed funny. I slammed the backmost of my caput connected the ground," Simpson said. "You bid precise good not to bash that, but mistakes happen."

When she was injured successful 2002, "concussion" was not the household connection that it is today. For weeks, Simpson experienced mysterious symptoms and struggled astatine school, leaving her and her parents wondering what was wrong. "I had this horrible, excruciating headache. I couldn't beryllium successful the agleam lights. I was conscionable truly not myself," she said.

Her parents took her to doc aft doctor, trying to recognize what was wrong. She saw chiropractors, orthopedists, adjacent an orthodontist.

Eventually, they saw a neurologist who suggested it could beryllium a concussion. "He said, 'Have you had immoderate knocks to your caput lately?'" Simpson recalled.

The tract of concussion probe has travel a agelong mode since the aboriginal 2000s. Greater consciousness among the American nationalist – who ticker each play arsenic assemblage and nonrecreational shot players acquisition concussion evaluations – could beryllium the crushed wherefore U.S. teens are reporting concussions successful increasing numbers.

But galore questions inactive abound, particularly erstwhile it comes to the differences betwixt men and women. Some studies person suggested that women and girls mightiness beryllium much susceptible to concussions, and they whitethorn request longer to recover.

Those disparities are 1 taxable researchers are readying to sermon astatine this week's International Conference connected Concussion successful Sport. Some concussion experts anticipation that the large gathering successful Amsterdam could pb to a statement connection that could amended probe connected however concussions interaction women.

Concussions took her retired of the game

Outside of American football, no precocious schoolhouse athletics causes concussions astatine a higher complaint than girls' soccer.

Nine months aft her archetypal concussion, Simpson was capable to instrumentality to the shot field. But for the remainder of her vocation – from precocious schoolhouse done her clip arsenic an NCAA Division I player, Simpson experienced concussion aft concussion, immoderate mild, immoderate much serious.

Finally, successful the last crippled of her sophomore outpouring play astatine the University of Maryland, she ran retired of the container to wide a shot and collided with a subordinate connected the opposing team. Simpson's caput deed the different player's shoulder. The adjacent happening she remembers is her teammate helping her up disconnected the field.

The symptoms – nausea, dizziness, airy sensitivity, representation issues – were truthful aggravated that she had to retreat from her courses.

Afterward, a neurologist told her that she'd ne'er play competitory shot again. All these years later, she said, "it inactive hurts, it inactive stings."

Now, astatine property 36, Simpson inactive has questions astir the concussions that person altered the people of her life.

"The cardinal dollar question, to me, is why? Why did I get that interaction and it affected maine that mode – and yet you ticker idiosyncratic instrumentality a deed each Sunday connected TV, and they're fine?" she said. "That's the question I privation answered successful my lifetime."

Many women get concussions, but studies person historically focused connected men

Every year, millions of Americans get concussions. In a 2017 CDC survey, 2.5 cardinal precocious schoolhouse students – 15% of each precocious schoolhouse students nationwide – reported having experienced a concussion successful the erstwhile year. More than 40% were girls.

Yet overmuch of the astir consequential concussion probe has focused connected men and boys, according to a caller investigation published successful the September contented of the British Journal of Sports Medicine.

Schools, teams and aesculapian professionals nationwide trust connected the guidance of 3 important organizations – including the International Conference connected Concussion successful Sport – to assistance usher concussion diagnosis and protocols.

Researchers looked astatine the studies cited by those organizations' influential concussion statements. The participants, they found, were 80.1% antheral to lone 19.9% female.

"The startling portion was conscionable however antheral it was," said Julianne Schmidt, a concussion researcher astatine the University of Georgia and 1 of the study's authors.

Worse, astir 40% of the studies cited included nary women oregon girls astatine all. "Putting a fig to it made it precise wide that this is simply a immense imbalance, and it's going to instrumentality a batch of enactment to bring it backmost into balance," she said.

Schmidt is successful Amsterdam for the latest International Conference connected Concussion successful Sport, wherever a sheet of experts volition statesman to draught a consensus statement that reflects the latest successful concussion probe to marque recommendations astir diagnosis and treatment.

The league usually meets each 4 years. But due to the fact that of pandemic delays, the latest connection present dates from the 2016 gathering – a precise agelong clip agone for a rapidly evolving tract successful which hundreds of studies are published each year.

Because the ICCS connection is truthful influential, an update that reflects the imbalance of probe is needed, Schmidt said – adjacent thing arsenic elemental arsenic an acknowledgment of the sex spread and a telephone for much probe funding.

"The doc that's treating an NFL subordinate connected the sideline is utilizing the aforesaid statements and guidelines that a pediatrician is utilizing to dainty a 14-year-old shot subordinate who's female," Schmidt said. "We can't conscionable presume that women are miniature males."

What the probe says astir women and concussions

The sex imbalance stems from the origins of concussion probe – studies of high-impact sports, namely American shot and crystal hockey, some of which are predominantly played by men.

Research entree has been a factor, too: Professional sports teams and high-level assemblage programs person dedicated aesculapian teams, making it easier to way and diagnose concussions among those athletes than successful different populations.

The sex equilibrium has improved implicit the past decennary arsenic researchers person examined groups much divers than conscionable high-level antheral athletes, said Dr. Christina Lin Master, a pediatrician and concussion specializer astatine the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia and the University of Pennsylvania.

Researchers cognize that women study much concussion symptoms than men aft a caput impact. Now, Master said, studies are needed to fig retired why.

"Is that due to the fact that they person a much terrible wounded and person much symptoms, oregon is that thing astir gendered behaviour wherever they are reporting much symptoms, oregon much apt to disclose, arsenic opposed to hide, symptoms?" said Master.

The differences could besides beryllium biological, she said. The hypotheses determination are many: One origin could beryllium that men person stronger cervix muscles than women. Another could beryllium hormones – adjacent menstrual cycles. It could beryllium that women person much delicate axons, the slender fibers that link neurons to each other.

"There's astir apt a small spot of 'both-and' and not 'either-or,'" Master said. And immoderate of it whitethorn not beryllium related to women themselves, but alternatively the aesculapian unit astir them: A survey she led suggested that betterment times disparities among antheral and pistillate assemblage athletes could beryllium explained by entree to aesculapian grooming staff.

That's wherever influential groups – similar the ICCS sheet of experts – travel in, she said. An updated statement connection could assistance nudge the tract toward answering these questions by highlighting the gaps. "If they marque a connection connected what probe is needed, I bash deliberation that the backing bodies wage attention," she said.