Elon Musk took over a struggling business with Twitter and has quickly made it worse - CNBC

When Elon Musk said past week that Twitter has experienced a "massive driblet successful revenue" nether his caller tutelage, helium blamed the diminution connected "activist groups pressuring advertisers."

There was immoderate merit to his claim. A radical of civilian rights leaders had sent a missive to the CEOs of large companies, including Anheuser-Busch, Apple, Coca-Cola and Disney, urging them to relay their concerns astir marque information connected the tract to Musk. Later, the radical would telephone for those businesses to halt advertisement spending connected Twitter pursuing what its leaders saw arsenic a emergence of racist posts and hatred speech.

While Musk whitethorn beryllium close to property immoderate of the gross driblet to activistic pressure, helium whitethorn besides privation to see accepting immoderate responsibility. Twitter's caller owner, the world's richest person, precocious tweeted a conspiracy mentation related to the onslaught connected Paul Pelosi, hubby of House Speaker Nandy Pelosi, and has made a bid of crude and sophomoric jokes, immoderate of which he's rapidly deleted.

Businesses don't privation to nexus their brands with that benignant of behaviour and content, said Rachel Tipograph, CEO of advertizing exertion steadfast MikMak.

"There's concerns with advertisers astir marque safety, and that's truly what this is each about," Tipograph said. "Advertisers close present are not looking to beryllium associated with the events that are presently happening astatine Twitter."

Companies similar General Motors and Volkswagen person paused their spending connected Twitter pursuing Musk's arrival, portion advertizing titan Interpublic Group recommended that its clients bash the same. The boycott poses a important occupation for the societal media service, which derives 90% of income from advertising.

Compared to larger rivals Facebook and Google, Twitter ne'er managed to make an online advertisement concern that matched the standard of its power successful fashionable civilization and nine astatine large. Twitter has mislaid wealth successful six of the 8 years since its IPO. Its gross successful 2021 reached $5 billion, portion Facebook generated income of $118 cardinal and Google genitor Alphabet recorded $257 cardinal successful revenue.

Twitter's gross successful the second quarter declined from a twelvemonth earlier.

"In my humble opinion, to usage a precise method term, their concern sucks, and they request a extremist transformation," said Len Sherman, an adjunct prof of concern astatine Columbia Business School.

It's a concern that Musk shelled retired $44 cardinal to purchase. As portion of the deal, helium borrowed $13 billion, which helium has to wage back.

For that investment, helium got a institution with "very mediocre targeting capabilities successful an ad-based concern wherever that's essential," Sherman said. "I benignant of laughter due to the fact that I support getting Twitter promoted ads successful my watercourse for companies that would beryllium amended directed to 13-year-old girls."

On Wednesday, Musk is holding an audio gathering with advertisers connected "Twitter Spaces."

Twitter didn't respond to requests for comment.

Musk did himself nary favors aft the acquisition, which closed successful precocious October. In summation to his ain questionable tweets and retweets, he's been inconsistent successful laying retired what helium means by escaped code and acceptable contented connected the platform, and helium abruptly fired astir 50% of Twitter's unit astir immediately, raising further questions astir contented moderation.

Companies typically halt their advertizing campaigns if they consciousness they whitethorn endure reputational damage. For example, businesses boycotted Alphabet's YouTube successful 2017 implicit concerns their ads would beryllium played alongside extremists' videos.

YouTube executives responded rapidly astatine the time, allowing third-party verification of content, and hired much radical to region the violative videos. Advertisers came backmost and the concern rebounded promptly.

Musk would alternatively instrumentality a combative attack to advertisers. In effect to a tweet recommending that helium sanction the brands that are boycotting Twitter truthful that his followers tin crook astir and boycott them, Musk said "a thermonuclear sanction & shame is precisely what volition hap if this continues."

Meanwhile, Musk is taking a convoluted attack to banning users. Comedian Kathy Griffin was booted for impersonating Musk connected the site, portion Sarah Silverman had her relationship locked temporarily for a akin offense.

Jeff Seibert, Twitter's erstwhile caput of user product, called it "a mistake for Elon to beryllium the look of contented moderation." In the past, Twitter has taken a squad attack to argumentation violations.

"If you enactment 1 idiosyncratic successful complaint of it, I deliberation you commencement seeing random decisions similar this that past [cause radical to] suffer trust," Seibert said.

Twitter's advertizing concern has already started deteriorating nether Musk.

Data from MikMak, whose clients see Colgate, Unilever and General Mills, amusement a wide pullback successful advertisement spending connected Twitter. From Oct. 1 done Nov. 7, Twitter suffered a 68% driblet successful media traffic, which refers to the fig of times radical click connected an ad, according to MikMak.

Before that, the numbers had been going up. Twitter's media postulation accrued 56.3% from July 1 to Sept. 30, and 326% from April 1 done June 30.

"We were really seeing an uptick successful Twitter traffic," Tipograph said. "As soon arsenic Elon Musk's imaginable ownership was becoming much imminent, we importantly saw a alteration successful traffic."

Whatever tech and concern improvements were taking spot volition beryllium hard to sustain, arsenic the wide layoffs ate into Twitter's planetary selling team, whose responsibilities see reporting and metrics astir advertisement performance, CNBC reported.

Musk has turned his absorption to subscriptions arsenic the cardinal to reviving Twitter's financials. He's pitched an $8-a-month offering that allows radical to beryllium "verified" and summation premium features. The critics person been truthful vociferous that Musk connected Monday tweeted an representation of a t-shirt, speechmaking "Your feedback is appreciated. Now wage $8."

Musk has antecedently hinted that helium wants to person Twitter into a alleged ace app, akin to China's WeChat, that radical tin usage to speech to friends, ticker movies and bargain goods.

Still, he'll request partners that privation to enactment with him. And his assertive stance towards companies that person paused ads connected the tract isn't a bully look arsenic helium pursues different partnerships, said Jeanine Turner, a prof successful Georgetown University's Communication, Culture and Technology program.

The "big contented for him I would deliberation would beryllium trust," Turner said. "I don't spot radical trusting him with each of that information."

As for advertisers, galore brands don't see Twitter an indispensable avenue for organisation considering its little blase ad-tracking exertion and targeting capabilities. Other opportunities are emerging, specified arsenic connected TVs and streaming services arsenic good arsenic Amazon's increasing online advertisement concern for retail-oriented companies, Tipograph said.

Jessica González, the co-CEO of nonprofit radical Free Press, has been unimpressed with Musk's antics. Gonzalez was 1 of the civilian rights leaders who spoke to Musk past week, expressing interest astir the emergence of hatred code against Black and Jewish groups connected Twitter. It's the aforesaid radical that was urging advertisers to halt their campaigns.

González said she was consenting to springiness Musk "the payment of the doubt" erstwhile helium told the radical that Twitter was aligned with them. But betwixt his rhetoric that followed and his slashing of fractional the staff, she has superior doubts astir whether it's worthy trying to enactment with him.

When asked whether she would instrumentality different gathering with Musk to sermon Twitter's attack to violative content, she said, "I don't know."

"Only due to the fact that helium made immoderate promises successful that meeting, and past went backmost connected them similar 2 days later," González said.

WATCH: The opportunities astatine Twitter are gigantic