Germany's early exit will sting, but they will just be fine

DOHA, Qatar -- When you're a four-time World Cup winner, 2 consecutive first-round exits is bound to bring gnashing of teeth, pulling of hairsbreadth and the benignant of self-criticism that would person done Chairman Mao proud. That's what awaits Germany arsenic they question home.

It's going to beryllium a bummer of a vacation season, but successful these situations, it's besides worthy uncovering immoderate clarity. Identifying those areas of interest that are morganatic and those that travel down to luck and happenstance.

- World Cup 2022: News and features | Schedule

First, arsenic tempting arsenic it mightiness beryllium to bundle the 2 World Cup nightmares together, they are not the same. Four years ago, Germany were apical seeds and faced weaker absorption (Mexico, Sweden and South Korea) successful their group. They mislaid 2 games and bushed Sweden acknowledgment lone to an improbable Toni Kroos escaped footwear successful the 5th infinitesimal of wounded time.

This time, they paid a beloved terms for failing to adjacent retired the opener aft taking the pb against Japan (losing 2-1), battled apical effect Spain to a 1-1 gully and bushed Costa Rica successful the last radical game. Not great, but had it not been for Spain somehow managing to suffer to Japan, they would person been through. (Indeed, since teeny tiny margins abstracted agony and ecstasy successful a World Cup: the millimeters by which the shot remained successful play erstwhile Kaoru Mitoma crossed for Ao Tanaka for Japan's winning extremity are what sent them home.)

As successful 2018, Germany really won the expected goals conflict successful each of their 3 radical games, but this clip they did truthful by a monolithic borderline (plus-4.92, compared with plus-2.61 successful Russia). So let's beryllium clear: Germany were not terrible; they did capable to beforehand nether mean circumstances (Japan beating Spain is not mean circumstances); and they did not get the breaks.

- Connelly: Why each Round of 16 squad will, won't triumph the World Cup

That said, Hansi Flick and the players are not without blame. Far from it. Manuel Neuer mightiness inactive beryllium 1 of the champion goalkeepers successful the world, but helium surely did not play similar it successful Qatar. At a minimum, helium deserves to stock the blasted with Nico Schlotterbeck for that extremity conceded against Japan, portion the little said astir his show against Costa Rica, the better. Up front, the gaudy xG numbers bash you nary bully if you don't decorativeness properly, and determination has to beryllium an constituent of corporate blasted to that.

As for Flick, arsenic I spot it, determination are valid criticisms and little valid ones. Let's commencement with the latter.

Flick gets criticized for trying to import the Bayern Munich exemplary of play into the nationalist side, which leaves his squad excessively unfastened astatine the back. The conception that attacking shot works successful the nine crippled but the World Cup someway calls for debased blocks and antiaircraft prowess is vastly overblown. Sure, France won playing that mode and England reached the Euro 2020 last doing conscionable that, but that's not a important illustration size. It mightiness conscionable beryllium that Didier Deschamps and Gareth Southgate were much comfy playing that way. And, frankly, France had truthful overmuch endowment that it astir apt didn't substance however they approached the 2018 World Cup. As for England, you tin marque a precise beardown lawsuit that Southgate's defensiveness really outgo them the last arsenic they handed the inaugural to Italy.

A simpler, much rational mantra mightiness beryllium to play to your strengths and what your players are accustomed to doing. The bulk of the German broadside comes from Bayern, who onslaught and property high, arsenic bash Manchester City, wherever Ilkay Gundogan plays. Sticking to that publication makes sense, not to notation that if you acceptable up to play connected the counterattack and spell a extremity down, it's a heck of a batch much hard to past bash a 180 and spell connected the attack.

The different fallacious statement present is that Germany paid a beloved terms for the deficiency of a "proven center-forward." Evidence for this is, supposedly, the information that they did amended with Niclas Fullkrug -- an average, blue-collar feline with zero caps until a period agone -- than with Kai Havertz oregon Thomas Muller starring the line, neither of whom is considered a "proper" center-forward.

Let's disregard for a infinitesimal that neither Liverpool nor Manchester City, the astir ascendant teams successful the champion league for the past 5 seasons, person specified a fig (we're talking pre-Erling Haaland successful City's case). That's nine shot -- I know, it's supposedly an wholly antithetic athletics (see above). But Brazil and Argentina are, on with France, astir people's favorites, and they don't person a accepted center-forward.

So what gives? Mueller and Havertz were picked up of Fullkrug due to the fact that they are simply better. Sometimes we overcomplicate the game: it's inactive 10 outfield players moving and passing, dribbling and shooting, truthful it makes consciousness to get your champion guys connected the pitch. (It conscionable truthful happens that, successful this tournament, Fullkrug was much effective.)

play

2:26

ESPN FC's Archie Rhind-Tutt labels Germany's World Cup exit arsenic a debacle.

So what blasted can we laic connected Flick?

For a start, this is not a squad wherever the pieces acceptable unneurotic well, peculiarly successful the last third. He was incapable to find a solution to that, perchance because, similar astir coaches, helium had precise small prep time, perchance due to the fact that helium wasn't comfy making pugnacious decisions, similar handing the keys of the squad to midfielder Jamal Musiala, Germany's contiguous and aboriginal astatine this time. And possibly, helium misread the signifier of immoderate of his veterans (Neuer, Muller and Leon Goretzka outpouring to mind), opting for loyalty implicit productivity this season.

Flick's crippled absorption besides near a batch to beryllium desired, successful the 2nd fractional against Japan and successful the lucifer against Spain. He didn't marque the close adjustments erstwhile Japan made changes aft the break, and the vibe successful that 2nd fractional was mode excessively escaped and careless. Against Spain, it felt arsenic if Germany gave the absorption a small excessively overmuch respect, arsenic if the benefits of a triumph were outweighed by the harm of a loss. It was astir apt the calculation that a gully was conscionable fine, since Germany would bushed Costa Rica successful the last crippled and determination was nary mode Japan was going to decision Spain... a calculation that, arsenic we saw, proved to beryllium wholly incorrect.

Germany's absorption aft going a extremity down against Spain saw them play arguably their champion shot astatine the World Cup. With hindsight -- which is ever 20-20, of people -- that ought to person been the blueprint.

So what's next? Flick mightiness oregon mightiness not instrumentality around, and it mightiness not beryllium his prime anyway. The likes of Gundogan, Antonio Rudiger and Muller astir apt won't marque it to the adjacent cycle, but others volition emerge. And there's inactive plentifulness to travel from Joshua Kimmich, Leroy Sane, Serge Gnabry and, of course, Musiala. If they tin unlock the hypertalented enigma that is Havertz -- they'll request assistance from Chelsea connected that 1 -- past the instauration volition beryllium determination for different tally arsenic aboriginal arsenic the adjacent Euros successful 2024, wherever they'll beryllium the big nation.

Four years agone was a debased point. This time, it's much a lawsuit of tweaking and learning from your mistakes, particularly successful presumption of crippled absorption and knowing erstwhile to beryllium assured and erstwhile to beryllium humble. Germany volition beryllium conscionable fine.