Grenfell Tower fire: Contractors slammed for blaming each other

2 years ago 42

Grenfell Tower aft  the fireImage source, Getty Images

Image caption,

The Grenfell Tower Inquiry started successful September 2017

By Tom Symonds

BBC News Correspondent, astatine the Grenfell Tower Inquiry

The nationalist enquiry into the Grenfell Tower occurrence has drawn to a adjacent with a powerfully worded onslaught by a elder barrister connected companies and organisations progressive successful the tragedy.

Richard Millett KC, pb counsel for the inquiry, said the risks that led to the 2017 occurrence successful westbound London were "well known" by galore of them and "ought to person been known" by each of them.

He described "incompetence", "cynical" and "possibly dishonest practices" successful the gathering industry, "weak" gathering controls, nonaccomplishment of London Fire Brigade to larn lessons from erstwhile fires, and a nonaccomplishment of government.

He told the proceeding that, based connected the evidence, the sheet should reason that each 72 deaths arsenic a effect of the catastrophe successful northbound Kensington were "avoidable".

Mr Millet KC condemned the "failure to wage owed respect to the thought of the location arsenic a carnal facet of quality privacy, agency, information and dignity".

'Nobody to blame?'

Addressing enquiry seat Sir Martin Moore-Bick, helium said firms progressive successful the occurrence had often denied responsibility.

"If everything that has been said [at the inquiry] was correct, past cipher was to blasted for the Grenfell Tower fire. Can that truly beryllium right?

"Is the reply that you privation to springiness to the survivors, to the grieving families, and to the wider nationalist to beryllium that the Grenfell Tower occurrence was conscionable a unspeakable accident? Just 1 of those unfortunate incidents that happened occasionally?"

Or is it to be, helium said, that "there are truthful galore to blame, that nary 1 idiosyncratic oregon organisation shoulders precise overmuch blame".

That, helium said, is what the firms accused of immoderate work for the occurrence wanted him to conclude.

"Are they truly arsenic atrocious arsenic they say?" Mr Millet KC asked.

Image source, Reuters

Image caption,

Sir Martin Moore-Bick, the enquiry chair, and his sheet volition present determine who is to blasted for the fire

Since the archetypal time of the archetypal signifier of the inquiry, Mr Millett KC has criticised the gathering manufacture companies for blaming each different successful "indulging successful a merry-go-round of blame".

Referring to the companies' closing statements this week helium said "the merry-go-round turns still. The notes of its melody, intelligibly audible."

He went connected to say: "A calamity of these dimensions ought to person provoked a beardown consciousness of nationalist responsibility."

Instead, helium said, galore "core participants look simply to person utilized the enquiry arsenic an accidental to presumption themselves", truthful arsenic "to minimise their ain vulnerability to ineligible liability".

"A nationalist enquiry is not the spot for cleverness. But for candour."

Image source, Grenfell Tower Inquiry

Image caption,

Richard Millett KC showed the enquiry a diagram of the "web of blame" helium said had been woven by firms progressive successful the fire

He utilized the bulk of his closing code to acceptable retired the ways successful which helium believed the galore organisations and companies, which were progressive successful the refurbishment of the operation successful the years earlier the fire, had blamed each other.

Having heard the past of the closing statements, the enquiry sheet volition present determine which of them were astir liable for failures that led to the blaze.

  • Arconic Architectural Products: The enquiry has heard the cladding shaper marketed the cladding, knowing it would beryllium utilized connected gangly buildings, contempt having trial grounds that it mightiness beryllium unsafe for this purpose. Arconic, however, argues that it is the occupation of architects and operation firms to guarantee the materials they usage are suitable
  • Rydon: The sheet heard the gathering and plan contractor for the tower's refurbishment successful 2015 knew, oregon should person known, the cladding was flammable. Rydon says it was ne'er warned astir the hazard of the cladding by its shaper and relied connected different experts
  • The Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea (RBKC) and its tenant absorption organisation: The section assembly and the assemblage managing its societal lodging has been accused during the enquiry of trying to chopped costs by utilizing a cheaper, non-fire retardant benignant of cladding. The assembly has admitted its gathering inspectors signed-off connected the decision
  • Harley Facades: The contractor that bought and fitted the flammable cladding chosen by Rydon and the assembly has defended itself astatine the inquiry, saying it did not cognize the cladding had antecedently failed occurrence information tests. However, Arconic argued the cladding came with a certificate that said it was combustible and that the cladding panels had been misused arsenic they were not suitable for the tower
  • Celotex and Kingspan: During the enquiry the 2 insulation companies person been accused of ignoring information risks erstwhile selling products for residential operation blocks. They importune their products could beryllium utilized safely with the close designs
  • Exova: The enquiry has heard that occurrence information consultants had advised the refurbishment would person nary adverse effect connected information successful a study during the aboriginal readying stages for the Grenfell redevelopment. However, successful his closing connection connected Thursday, Sean Brannigan KC, representing the firm, said his lawsuit had "literally thing to do" with the determination to usage cladding containing a flammable integrative layer, which was taken aboriginal successful the project

On the inquiry's closing day, the authorities repeated its erstwhile apology for its nonaccomplishment to realise that the regulatory strategy for gathering information was "broken and mightiness pb to a catastrophe specified arsenic this".

Jason Beer KC, representing the Department for Housing, Communities and Levelling Up, said: "The section is genuinely atrocious and apologises unreservedly."

Image source, PA Media

Image caption,

Victims and bereaved relatives person campaigned for companies progressive successful the occurrence to beryllium held accountable

It is apt the enquiry volition not people its last study until good into 2023, and that decisions by constabulary and prosecutors astir whether transgression charges volition beryllium brought volition not beryllium made until 2024.

Bereaved relatives and survivors of the fire, on with residents of the property wherever Grenfell Tower stands, person said they volition not beryllium satisfied until those liable are sent to prison.

Additional reporting by Aurelia Foster

Follow BBC London connected Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. Send your communicative ideas to hellobbclondon@bbc.co.uk

Related Internet Links

The BBC is not liable for the contented of outer sites.

Read Entire Article