Labour plans to expand Lords despite abolition pledge

1 year ago 28

The House of LordsImage source, PA Media

By Helen Catt & Chas Geiger

BBC News

Labour has insisted it inactive wants to abolish the Lords, contempt readying to summation its size by creating caller peers if it wins the adjacent election.

Sir Keir Starmer's spokesperson said helium stood by a pledge to get escaped of the Lords during a archetypal word successful office, but determination could beryllium "interim reforms".

Currently, Labour would request 90 much peers to overtake the Conservatives' 263 successful the precocious chamber.

New Labour peers would beryllium expected to backmost abolition, the spokesperson said.

Earlier, The Times reported that Labour was readying to name dozens of peers to the Lords to forestall a Starmer authorities having its docket thwarted.

The spokesperson said helium did not recognise "arbitrary figures" and would not spell into timescales.

But helium admitted erstwhile governments had needed much than 1 word to make capable peers to guarantee they could get their concern done Parliament.

He said: "Every authorities erstwhile they archetypal travel into powerfulness bash not person a bulk wrong the House of Lords due to the fact that of the quality of the appointments process.

"And each authorities arsenic a substance of customized and signifier looks to marque appointments to the House of Lords, but it's not thing that's done successful 1 fell swoop, it's thing that takes clip and often takes much than a word successful authorities for that to happen."

Full details of the argumentation would beryllium acceptable retired up of the adjacent wide election, helium added.

But Labour's presumption raises a fig of questions, including wherefore name immoderate peers astatine each if the fig volition not marque Labour the largest enactment successful the Lords earlier it is abolished.

There would beryllium a question implicit who mightiness instrumentality a peerage portion having to perpetrate themselves to abolishing it wrong 5 years.

'Indefensible'

At present, determination are 174 Labour peers, 263 Conservatives, 84 Liberal Democrats and 183 unaligned crossbenchers.

In December, Sir Keir unveiled plans enactment guardant by erstwhile Prime Minister Gordon Brown for sweeping law changes, including replacing the Lords with an elected assembly representing the UK's nations and regions.

The Labour person described the House of Lords arsenic "indefensible".

Even earlier the caller peers nominated successful Boris Johnson's resignation honours database instrumentality up their positions, determination are presently 779 members of 1 of the world's biggest precocious chambers.

Lord Speaker Lord McFall, a erstwhile Labour MP, has argued that the Lords is excessively ample and that its numbers should beryllium reduced, but has pressed for betterment alternatively than abolition.

Sir Keir's spokesperson suggested reforms could instrumentality spot earlier afloat abolition, specified arsenic getting escaped of by-elections for the remaining hereditary peers.

"There whitethorn beryllium interim reforms on the way, I'm not ruling that out," helium said.

Former furniture minister, Tory MP Sir Simon Clarke, has described Lords abolition arsenic a "terrible idea".

"Anyone who has looked astatine the institutionalised gridlock successful US authorities tin spot the utter stupidity it would beryllium to make an elected precocious house," helium said.

Labour adjacent and erstwhile furniture curate Lord Mandelson has warned that, without statement from different parties, Labour's plans hazard dragging the enactment into a "quagmire", soaking up "acres of clip and energy" that would beryllium amended spent connected different priorities.

Read Entire Article