1 year ago
40
Smith, 57, was sentenced to decease implicit the jury's proposal of beingness successful prison.
Editor's note: Reporter Evan Mealins was successful Atmore, Alabama, connected Thursday to witnesser the execution of Kenneth Eugene Smith, who was sentenced to decease by judicial override for the 1988 murder-for-hire of Elizabeth Dorlene Sennett. Authorities judge Sennett's husband, preacher Charles Sennett Sr., arranged the execution to cod security payments for his debts. The pursuing are timestamped events arsenic they were reported connected Thursday.
Thursday, 11:20 p.m.: State halts execution
Alabama called disconnected Thursday night's execution of Kenneth Eugene Smith conscionable 40 minutes earlier his decease warrant was to expire astatine midnight.
Smith, 57, was scheduled to beryllium executed by lethal injection astatine 6 p.m. Thursday astatine Holman Correctional Facility successful Atmore, Alabama, for the declaration sidesplitting of a preacher's wife. But a bid of tribunal decisions delayed the commencement of his execution past 10 p.m., erstwhile the U.S. Supreme Court vacated a enactment successful the case.
Media representatives were enactment connected a van astatine 10:32 p.m., soon aft the Supreme Court vacated the stay, to question the little than five-minute thrust to Holman Correctional Facility to witnesser Smith's execution. But the van stayed parked extracurricular the media halfway astatine adjacent Fountain Correctional Facility.
About 40 minutes later, a situation officer's vigor alerted her to "stand down," and media witnesses were unloaded from the van.
This is the 2nd execution effort successful arsenic galore months that Alabama has failed to transportation out. The authorities called disconnected Alan Eugene Miller's scheduled Sept. 22 execution minutes earlier midnight arsenic it failed to found the indispensable intravenous lines for the lethal injection.
Officials with the Alabama Department of Corrections said they would code the media Thursday nighttime oregon aboriginal Friday, ADOC spokesperson Kelly Betts said.
Thursday, 10:22 p.m.: Supreme Court vacates stay, clearing mode for execution
The U.S. Supreme Court vacated the U.S. 11th Circuit Court of Appeal's stay, clearing the execution of Kenneth Eugene Smith. Justices Elena Kagan, Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson would contradict the state's application, according to the order.
The justices did not supply a written decision.
The 11th Circuit granted the enactment conscionable earlier 8 p.m. The state's decease warrant to execute Smith expires astatine midnight.
Thursday, 9:07 p.m.: Smith's lawyers reply successful U.S. Supreme Court
Smith's attorneys continued to propulsion backmost against the state's statement that Smith should person sought a enactment earlier, pointing retired that helium filed for a preliminary injunction — which, similar a stay, asks the authorities to halt an execution — successful his archetypal complaint.
Smith's attorneys accidental that the state's arguments are based connected the conception that helium should person filed a petition for a enactment erstwhile helium filed his complaint, earlier Alabama had acceptable his execution date, oregon aft his suit was dismissed successful territory court, astatine which constituent determination was nary assertion successful which to question relief.
"Mr. Smith is not astatine responsibility for the improper dismissal of his complaint. Nor is helium astatine responsibility for immoderate delay," Smith's attorneys wrote.
Smith's lawyers besides criticized the authorities for challenging Smith's evidence, including grounds from Alan Miller, Dr. Joel Zivot and the autopsy of Joe Nathan James, Jr. They accidental Smith was denied the accidental for find aft his assertion was dismissed.
"Defendant should not beryllium rewarded for moving retired the find clock," Smith's attorneys said.
More:Department of Corrections denies petition for Joe Nathan James Jr. execution records
Thursday, 8:22 p.m.: State appeals to U.S. Supreme Court
With little than 4 hours earlier Smith's decease warrant expires astatine midnight, the Alabama Attorney General's Office appealed the 11th Circuit's ruling granting a enactment of Smith's execution to the U.S.. Supreme Court. The AG's bureau erstwhile again attacked Smith's timing successful filing his petition for a enactment and preliminary injunction, calling it "gamesmanship" and "a gambit."
Smith's attorneys and the 11th Circuit Court, however, recovered that Smith had asked for injunctive alleviation from the beginning: his precise archetypal ailment contained a petition for a preliminary injunction.
The state's 43-page petition to vacate the enactment besides argues that the authorities should not look undue national interference successful carrying retired the decease penalty. "... [T]he Court has besides repeatedly recognized that 'equity indispensable beryllium delicate to the State’s beardown involvement successful enforcing its transgression judgement without undue interference from the national courts,'" the AG's bureau wrote.
Thursday, 7:57 p.m.: 11th Circuit grants enactment of Smith's execution
The U.S. 11th Circuit Court granted Smith's petition for a enactment of his execution. The tribunal sided with Smith successful his claims that helium has diligently pursued his claims and sought a preliminary injunction earlier the time of his scheduled execution.
"Smith has continuously sought to rectify that dismissal since past and has pursued his claims diligently done the territory tribunal and here. We further reason that the different factors favour granting a stay," Judges Charles Wilson, Jill Pryor and Britt Grant wrote.
About Smith's crimes and earlier appeals
Prosecutors said Smith and 2 different men killed Elizabeth Dorlene Sennett successful 1988 aft her husband, preacher Charles Sennett Sr., arranged the execution to cod security payments for his debts.
Prosecutors said Charles Sennett Sr. hired Billy Gray Williams, 1 of his tenants, to person his woman killed. Williams recruited John Forrest Parker and Smith, paying them $1,000 each portion pocketing $1,000 for himself. Court documents amusement that Elizabeth Sennett was beaten and stabbed 8 times astatine her location successful Cherokee, a agrarian municipality successful Colbert County.
Charles Sennett Sr. died by termination a week aboriginal aft learning helium had been named a fishy successful the case.
Parker was executed by lethal injection successful 2010. In quality reports, Parker is quoted successful his past words arsenic telling Elizabeth Sennett's sons, "I’m sorry. I don’t ever expect you to forgive me. I truly americium sorry."
Williams was sentenced to beingness without parole and died successful authorities custody connected Nov. 22, 2020, according to the Alabama Department of Corrections.
Smith's attorneys requested a enactment of his execution successful the U.S. Middle District of Alabama successful August, claiming that complications astatine caller executions enactment him astatine an intolerable hazard of cruel and antithetic punishment and that helium was not afloat informed of his enactment to elite nitrogen hypoxia. U.S. District Judge R. Austin Huffaker Jr. denied his petition for a stay.
Smith aboriginal appealed to the U.S. 11th Circuit Court of Appeals and the U.S. Supreme Court. In his exertion for a enactment to the U.S. Supreme Court, Smith's attorneys argued that his decease condemnation was unconstitutional due to the fact that helium could not beryllium sentenced to decease by judicial override today.
Thursday, 6:29 p.m.: Smith's attorneys effort different entreaty to 11th Circuit
After Smith's question for a enactment was denied successful the territory court, his attorneys appealed the ruling to the 11th Circuit. Smith's attorneys are asking the tribunal to assistance the enactment that the territory tribunal denied, and to support that enactment successful spot until it has clip to regularisation connected Smith's petition for a preliminary injunction based connected his Eighth Amendment claims.
The 11th Circuit earlier Thursday recovered that Smith plausibly pleaded "he volition look superadded symptom arsenic the execution squad attempts to summation IV access.”
Smith's attorneys argued against the state's assertion that his requests for a enactment were not timely. Smith's attorneys planned to record a question for a preliminary injunction, but they said the tribunal dismissed Smith's lawsuit earlier they were capable to get indispensable accusation done discovery.
"After the tribunal scheduled oral statement connected the question to dismiss, Mr. Smith served find and moved to expedite find and acceptable a scheduling bid for Mr. Smith’s anticipated preliminary injunction motion," his attorneys wrote.
"There is an intolerable hazard that Mr. Smith volition beryllium subjected to torture, cruelty, and important symptom arsenic evidenced by the State’s astir caller execution attempts, adjacent though helium was deprived of the prime to elite nitrogen hypoxia. The past 2 execution attempts resulted successful violations of rights and a implicit disregard for quality dignity. While the nationalist indisputably has an involvement successful ensuring that sentences are carried out, that involvement does not widen to executing Mr. Smith successful usurpation of his Eighth Amendment rights."
Thursday, 5:55 p.m.: Judge denies Smith's motions for enactment and preliminary injunction
After Smith's lawsuit was remanded to him from the U.S. 11th Circuit, U.S. District Judge R. Austin Huffaker denied Smith's motions for a enactment and preliminary injunction of his execution by lethal injection. Huffaker agreed with the authorities that Smith "inexcusably delayed" filing his motion.
"The Court agrees with the Commissioner that Smith inexcusably delayed filing his question for a enactment and finds that the question is owed to beryllium denied due to the fact that the equities measurement against the granting of a stay," Huffaker wrote.
Smith's attorneys filed a announcement to the territory tribunal of their program to entreaty the ruling.
Thursday, 5:28 p.m.: ADOC shares Smith's past meals, visitors
Smith was visited by household members Wednesday and Thursday, according to a database of his activities shared by the Alabama Department of Corrections.
Several household members, Smith lawyer Robert Grass, and Smith’s spiritual adviser, Dan Blocker, visited Smith astatine Holman connected Thursday. Smith refused meal connected Thursday.
Thursday, 3:45 p.m.: Smith's attorneys question exigency enactment of execution
Smith's attorneys filed with the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Alabama an exigency question for a enactment and a question for a preliminary injunction of Smith's pending execution. Huffaker held a telephone league astatine 3:45 p.m. to sermon the motions with Smith's attorney, Andy Johnson, and attorneys for the state, Richard Anderson and Thomas Wilson.
"The Eleventh Circuit’s ... determination compels this Court to participate a enactment of execution to spend Mr. Smith the accidental to litigate his preliminary injunction question connected a afloat record," Smith's attorneys wrote successful the exigency question for a stay.
Huffaker volition reappraisal the question for a enactment and question for preliminary injunction and said during the telephone league that helium volition regularisation connected the motions "shortly."
The Alabama Attorney General's Office successful an opposing little called Smith's question for a preliminary injunction "sheer, cynical maneuvering," accusing his attorneys of waiting until the past infinitesimal to record successful bid to summation the chances of Smith's execution being delayed. Smith had connected Monday requested injunctive alleviation -- which would halt his execution -- from the 11th Circuit, but ne'er from the Middle District court, the AG's bureau noted.
"In sum, “[t]he radical of [Alabama], the surviving victims of Mr. [Smith’s] crimes, and others similar them merit better” than last-minute attempts to maltreatment the judicial process to unit the State to hold a lawful execution," the AG's bureau wrote.
Thursday, 2:58 p.m.: 11th Circuit reverses, remands lawsuit to territory court
A three-judge sheet voted 2-1 to nonstop Smith's lawsuit backmost to the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Alabama, which it said erred successful not allowing Smith to record an amended ailment successful his suit against the state. The lawsuit is backmost earlier Huffaker.
The 11th Circuit wrote Smith "plausibly alleged" that ADOC volition person "extreme difficulty" successful accessing his veins.
The judges quoted Dr. Joel Zivot, an anesthesiologist who provided an adept declaration successful Smith's case, penning that Smith's “risks [for] a failed intravenous effort are precise apt rather akin successful condition to the caller failed effort astatine IV entree of” Alan Miller.
"After reviewing Smith’s projected amended ailment de novo, we reason that helium pleaded capable facts to plausibly enactment an Eighth Amendment method-of-execution assertion that is not barred by the applicable statute of limitations, and frankincense amendment would not person been futile," the tribunal wrote. It continued that Smith “plausibly pleaded that, considering ADOC’s inability to found hard IVs swiftly and successfully successful the past, helium volition look superadded symptom arsenic the execution squad attempts to summation IV access.”
Judge Britt Grant dissented, penning that Smith's claims should beryllium time-barred since ADOC has agelong struggled to timely found IV access, opening with Doyle Lee Hamm successful 2018.
"But unluckily for everyone involved, the Department’s problems successful rapidly establishing IV entree for lethal injection are thing new," Grant wrote. Grant besides said the territory court's bid "prohibiting" deviations from the state's execution protocol mooted Smith's claims that the hazard of deviations from that protocol were intolerable.
Thursday, 12:45 p.m.: Former Gov. Don Siegelman protests execution
Former Gov. Don Siegelman is asking Alabama residents to telephone Gov. Kay Ivey to halt Smith's execution.
In the email sent Thursday, Siegelman said Ivey should temporarily halt executions portion the authorities figures retired however to forestall "the missteps successful caller attempts astatine lethal injections."
Siegelman, who was politician of Alabama from 1999 to 2003, besides said the Legislature should see whether the 2017 prohibition connected judicial overrides — specified an override successful 1996 enactment Smith connected decease enactment alternatively of the jury's penchant of beingness successful situation — should beryllium retroactive.
"This conscionable doesn’t marque sense: Is it motivation to execute idiosyncratic based connected a instrumentality Alabama has present repealed?" helium asked successful his email.
Siegelman was the past Democrat to service arsenic politician successful Alabama. While helium was successful office, the authorities executed 8 decease enactment inmates, including Lynda Lyon Block, the archetypal pistillate to beryllium executed successful Alabama since 1957.
Convicted successful 2006 connected charges of bribery and obstruction of justice, helium served a full of 5 years successful national situation earlier his merchandise successful February 2017. He appeared successful Montgomery successful precocious 2017 and said helium planned to enactment connected transgression justness issues.
Thursday a.m.: Smith refuses to comply with vein examination
In a tribunal filing Thursday morning, Holman Correctional Facility Warden Terry Raybon said Smith had refused to comply with a vein introspection anterior to his scheduled execution.
"I americium not going to springiness you each immoderate trouble, but I americium not going to enactment successful this," Smith is said to person told Raybon.
Huffaker had ordered the ADOC to "strictly follow" its execution protocol, which calls for an introspection of the condemned inmate's veins successful the days earlier his execution.
"Defendant believes that the inability to behaviour the vein introspection owed to Defendant’s refusal to cooperate with ADOC unit should not beryllium considered a usurpation of this Court’s order," Attorney General Steve Marshall wrote.
Alan Eugene Miller, whose scheduled Sept. 22 execution was called disconnected arsenic the execution squad failed to acceptable 2 IVs for the lethal injection, besides refused to let unit to analyse his veins earlier his execution, citing a preliminary injunction barring his execution by lethal injection that was aboriginal overturned.
Wednesday, 5:30 p.m.: U.S. Supreme Court declines to halt execution implicit 'judicial override'
The U.S. Supreme Court Wednesday evening denied Smith's exertion to enactment his execution, clearing the mode for his lethal injection Thursday night.
Smith was archetypal convicted successful 1989 and sentenced to death. His condemnation was overturned connected appeal, and a assemblage successful 1996 voted 11-1 to condemnation Smith to beingness successful situation without the anticipation of parole. The proceedings justice overrode the jury's determination and imposed the decease penalty.
When Alabama abolished judicial override successful 2017, it did not use to erstwhile sentences.
The U.S. Supreme Court denied the exertion astatine 5:30 p.m. Wednesday night, a small much than 24 hours earlier Smith's scheduled execution. The exertion for a enactment was presented to Justice Clarence Thomas who referred the exertion to the remainder of the court. The justices did not supply an mentation of their determination and did not database immoderate dissenting justices.
Smith's attorneys submitted the petition for a enactment to the tribunal connected Monday.
“If Mr. Smith’s proceedings had occurred today, helium could not person been eligible for execution. Nor would helium beryllium taxable to execution anyplace other successful the United States, arsenic each authorities that erstwhile permitted the signifier of judicial override has abandoned it,” Smith's attorneys wrote to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Wednesday, 1:30 p.m.: Smith's attorneys reason earlier 11th Circuit
Smith's attorney, Robert Grass, argued earlier the U.S. 11th Circuit Court of Appeals astatine 1:30 p.m. Wednesday, arguing that difficulties astatine caller executions and execution attempts made it apt that Alabama would taxable Smith to an unnecessarily cruel execution successful usurpation of the Eighth Amendment. The 11th Circuit had not issued a ruling arsenic of Thursday morning.
During oral arguments, 1 of 3 judges asked Thomas Wilson, a lawman solicitor wide representing the authorities successful Smith's litigation, however galore times it could poke an inmate successful attempts to found IV access. Wilson did not supply an answer.
Evan Mealins is the justness newsman for the Montgomery Advertiser. Contact him at emealins@gannett.com or travel him connected Twitter @EvanMealins.
Your subscription makes our journalism possible. Subscribe today.
English (US)