Oklahoma executes Benjamin Cole for the murder of his 9-month-old daughter - CNN

CNN  — 

[Breaking quality update astatine 11:37 a.m. ET]

Oklahoma has executed Benjamin Cole, a 57-year-old antheral who was convicted and sentenced to decease for the 2002 execution of his 9-month-old daughter.

“The condemnation of Benjamin Cole has been carried out,” Justin Wolf, a spokesperson for the Oklahoma Department of Corrections told reporters. “The clip of decease was 10:22 a.m. (CT).”

Cole’s attorneys opposed his execution, arguing their client, who was diagnosed with schizophrenia, was severely mentally sick and did not recognize the ineligible proceedings surrounding his execution.

[Previous story, published astatine 5:45 a.m. ET]

Oklahoma is expected to proceed its series of much than 2 twelve executions connected Thursday, erstwhile it is scheduled to enactment to decease Benjamin Cole, a 57-year-old antheral convicted for the execution of his 9-month-old daughter.

But successful the 2 decades since the crime, the decease enactment inmate’s declining intelligence information – magnified by his vulnerability arsenic a kid to drugs and alcohol, substance maltreatment issues and carnal and intersexual maltreatment – has deteriorated truthful overmuch that Cole is not competent to beryllium executed, his attorneys argued successful a clemency petition.

Their assertions enactment beforehand and halfway a longstanding question successful the statement implicit superior punishment: however it should use to those who endure from intelligence illness. The contented is cardinal successful a fig of inmates’ cases, according to their attorneys, arsenic Oklahoma officials program done 2024 to transportation retired 25 executions, a spree critics person besides condemned amid the state’s history of botched lethal injections.

The US Supreme Court connected Wednesday denied Cole’s petition for a enactment of execution after the authorities parole committee past month declined to urge clemency. Meanwhile, the inmate’s lawyers person asked a authorities appeals tribunal to compel the inmate’s warden to notation his lawsuit for reappraisal to the territory lawyer to initiate a competency hearing.

The facts of Cole’s lawsuit obligate the authorities to spare his life, his attorneys successful caller months told parole committee members, though the arguments failed. They pointed to “evolving standards of decency,” including public polling that shows disapproval for executions of the mentally ill.

“At this moment,” the attorneys wrote, “Oklahoma has the accidental to grounds courage, to travel these standards, and to beryllium connected the close broadside of past by prohibiting the execution of Benjamin Cole, a severely mentally sick and physically infirm person.”

The US Supreme Court successful a 1986 ruling recovered the execution of the severely mentally sick to beryllium unconstitutional, with Justice Thurgood Marshall writing, “It is nary little abhorrent contiguous than it has been for centuries to nonstop successful penance the beingness of 1 whose intelligence unwellness prevents him from comprehending the reasons for the punishment oregon its implications.” And successful Oklahoma, authorities instrumentality makes it amerciable to execute idiosyncratic recovered to beryllium insane.

Cole, who has been diagnosed with schizophrenia and has a encephalon lesion associated with Parkinson’s disease, lives successful a mostly “catatonic” state, hardly speaking to anyone, including his ain lawyers, according to his clemency petition. After years of near-total isolation successful the Oklahoma State Penitentiary, helium uses a wheelchair and exists successful what 1 objective scientist described successful the clemency petition arsenic his ain “mental universe,” not knowing the ineligible proceedings surrounding his imminent execution.

“Benjamin Cole is incapacitated by his intelligence unwellness to the constituent of being fundamentally non-functional,” his attorney, Tom Hird, said successful a connection aft an Oklahoma justice this period ruled Cole was competent to beryllium executed.

“His ain attorneys person not been capable to person a meaningful enactment with him for years, and the unit who interact with him successful the situation each time corroborate that helium cannot pass oregon instrumentality attraction of his astir basal hygiene. He simply does not person a rational knowing of wherefore Oklahoma seeks to execute him.”

Oklahoma Attorney General John O’Connor praised the parole board’s September ballot successful a statement, noting Cole’s condemnation and condemnation person been upheld connected entreaty and rejecting questions astir Cole’s intelligence illness.

“Although his attorneys assertion Cole is mentally sick to the constituent of catatonia, the information is that Cole afloat cooperated with a intelligence valuation successful July of this year,” the lawyer wide said September 27. “The evaluator, who was not hired by Cole oregon the State, recovered Cole to beryllium competent to beryllium executed and that ‘Mr. Cole does not presently grounds immoderate substantial, overt signs of intelligence illness, intelligence impairment, and/or neurocognitive impairment.’

“I americium grateful that the Board denied Cole’s petition for enforcement clemency. Our thoughts and prayers are with the different members” of the slain infant’s family.

Cole was recovered blameworthy of the brutal execution of his daughter, Brianna Victoria Cole, connected December 20, 2002, per the lawyer general’s office, erstwhile her cries interrupted him portion playing a video game.

Cole grabbed his daughter’s ankles portion she was connected her tummy and forced them up to her head, breaking her spine and causing her to bleed to death, according to a probable origin affidavit. Cole past returned to his video crippled arsenic his girl died, O’Connor said.

Cole admitted successful a taped confession to causing his daughter’s fatal injuries, his clemency petition said, telling constabulary helium would “regret his actions for the remainder of his life.”

Before his trial, prosecutors offered him a plea woody that would person resulted successful a beingness condemnation without parole. But Cole, his intelligence authorities already deteriorating, refused to judge it – a “complete enactment of irrationality against self-interest,” his petition said.

Cole wanted the lawsuit to spell to proceedings because, helium told his lawyers, it was “God’s will” and “his communicative … would alteration Rogers County, and it would let God to interaction hearts and let Benjamin to locomotion distant from it each a escaped man.”

Cole had yet to beryllium diagnosed with schizophrenia, but his proceedings attorneys doubly called for competency evaluations, arguing his spiritual delusions rendered him irrational and, arsenic a result, helium did not recognize the ineligible proceedings. Still, helium was recovered competent to basal trial.

Cole’s attorneys contiguous contend his lawyers astatine trial, on with the justice and bailiff, recognized the prevalence of his intelligence unwellness arsenic the antheral sat successful the proceedings “literally not moving a musculus for hours connected extremity with a Bible opened successful beforehand of him connected the table,” according to the petition. Cole did not attest and was sentenced to death.

Cole’s struggles with his intelligence wellness day backmost to his aboriginal childhood, increasing up successful a junkyard surrounded by “rampant” cause and intoxicant abuse, his petition said. Encouraged by the adults successful his life, Cole began to portion arsenic a young child, it said, and 1 of Cole’s brothers testified they would get precocious huffing gasoline by the clip Cole was 10 years old. Cole besides endured years of verbal, physical, and intersexual abuse, the petition claimed.

Cole graduated precocious school, but astir that clip helium began exhibiting “all of the marks of a idiosyncratic opening to conflict with superior intelligence illness,” the clemency petition said, noting 18 is the emblematic property erstwhile early-adult onset terrible intelligence illnesses similar schizophrenia archetypal emerge.

Cole became “isolated and withdrawn,” and a stepsister said helium was depressed and didn’t person galore friends, the petition said. He spent agelong periods unemployed, and though helium joined the Air Force successful 1986, helium struggled with substance abuse, exhibited “impulse power problems” and was discharged the pursuing year.

It was astir this clip Cole’s archetypal woman accused him of abusing their son, and Cole was convicted and sentenced to 2 years successful situation for aggravated kid abuse, the petition said. That matrimony ended, arsenic did Cole’s second, and erstwhile helium met Brianna’s parent successful 1998, helium was surviving either nether a span oregon successful a structure successful Claremore, Oklahoma.

When their girl was born, the petition said, Cole couldn’t support a occupation and was “drinking heavily.”

Cole’s information has gotten worse successful the years since his trial, years successful which teams of post-conviction attorneys struggled to meaningfully pass with him arsenic a tiny parade of psychologists and psychiatrists evaluated his declining intelligence state, the petition states.

One diagnosed Cole with paranoid schizophrenia successful 2008, uncovering his intelligence information had deteriorated arsenic helium went untreated for astir 20 years.

That doc besides said Cole was “convinced” immoderate treatment astir his lawsuit “would undermine his religion successful Jesus and undermine his existent ‘saved’ status,” the petition states. Those beliefs underscore what his lawyers picture arsenic an “implacable reticence” that interferes with their quality to enactment with him connected his case.

His clemency petition details visits by attorneys and doctors who recovered Cole soiled and “unkempt” successful implicit acheronian wrong his cell, which helium reportedly astir ne'er leaves. Corrections officers and his lawsuit manager person told Cole’s attorneys helium keeps the lights disconnected astatine astir each times and has nary respect for his idiosyncratic hygiene, per the petition.

In 2015, Cole mailed his parent immoderate of his hairsbreadth and a tooth, and successful 2019 helium handed 1 of his attorneys a packet with 2 much of his teeth and a enactment the attorneys understood arsenic a petition to message the teeth to his parent – some instances his clemency petition said exemplify his crisp decline.

Additionally, per his petition, a doc who reviewed an MRI performed connected Cole this twelvemonth recovered a lesion connected his encephalon that “would beryllium highly consistent” with Parkinsonism.