Editor’s Note: Megan Ranney, MD, MPH, is the lawman dean astatine the School of Public Health astatine Brown University and a prof of exigency medicine astatine the University’s Warren Alpert Medical School. The views expressed successful this commentary are her own. Read more opinion connected CNN.
CNN —
As a physician, a nationalist wellness nonrecreational and a genitor of a teenage girl, I’ve been pursuing quality astir a Florida schoolhouse district’s decision to digitize kids’ schoolhouse diversion records with involvement – and with concern.
What should beryllium a elemental determination astir aesculapian champion signifier has been turned into a Gordian knot of not conscionable health, but besides policy, politics, exertion and bodily autonomy.
Being progressive is evidently important for kids, successful general. We should bash everything we tin to promote each younker to prosecute successful carnal activity, whether done organized sports oregon informal activity. Although, traditionally, women were little apt to beryllium competitory athletes, the fig of US precocious schoolhouse athletes who place arsenic pistillate has accrued more than 10-fold over the past 5 decades. This maturation deserves to beryllium supported.
For kids of each genders to safely enactment successful competitory sports, a consortium of aesculapian organizations person agreed connected a standardized pre-sports carnal screening and exam. The nonstop rules and regulations disagree betwixt states, but the overarching extremity of a pre-sports carnal is to let physicians (or different due clinicians) to place and past mitigate imaginable harms from younker sports participation.
The pre-sports valuation form utilized by the Florida High School Athletic Association, and by hold the Palm Beach County School District, includes screening for everything from household past of cardiac disorders to concussions, slump and eating disorders. These questions are included for bully reason. Competitive athletes of each genders are prone to vigor deficiency, whether owed to disordered eating oregon owed to excessive vigor use during practices. This vigor deficiency tin origin long-lasting harm, particularly for adolescents.
When the vigor deficiency is accompanied by amenorrhea (lack of a period), it is particularly worrisome, as the metabolic and endocrine side-effects tin weaken athletes’ bones, summation the hazard of accent fractures and summation the hazard of semipermanent osteoporosis. It is, therefore, medically appropriate to inquire athletes astir signs of disordered eating, amenorrhea, and different signs of carnal information erstwhile deciding whether an jock is harmless to signifier and compete. This is besides the crushed the screening signifier besides includes 4 questions for “females only” astir menstruation.
However, determination is simply a large quality betwixt a doc oregon different trained healthcare nonrecreational asking these questions successful private, arsenic portion of a objective assessment, and the doc sharing each the details with 3rd parties.
That immoderate states whitethorn stock the afloat carnal and screening exam – including accusation astir younker athletes’ menstrual cycles – with schoolhouse districts, authorities officials and third-party integer record-keeping companies is, to me, profoundly worrisome. The strictures of the post-Dobbs world, the world of today’s tech satellite and the suggestive examples of different instances wherever these intersections person near women and girls susceptible could enactment parents and doctors successful an untenable position.
From a purely aesculapian perspective, the pre-participation exam forms approved by the American Academy of Family Physicians, American Academy of Pediatrics, American College of Sports Medicine, American Medical Society for Sports Medicine, American Orthopaedic Society for Sports Medicine, and American Osteopathic Academy of Sports Medicine, specify that lone the last determination (e.g., whether oregon not a diligent is cleared for sports, and whether determination are restrictions) should beryllium shared with a schoolhouse district. They specifically remark that the aesculapian exam and screening questions should stay with the evaluating clinician oregon physician.
This guidance reflects the tremendous value of protecting the privateness of the patient-physician relationship. The confidentiality of objective discussions is important successful general, but all the much truthful for adolescents. And reproductive and gynecologic care, including discussions astir menstruation, are appropriately considered to beryllium adjacent much backstage than, say, a lung oregon bosom oregon genu exam.
But my interest astir the reported sharing of information goes beyond fears of impairing the patient-physician relationship. The existent social, governmental and technological situation creates a cleanable tempest for this information-sharing to endanger younker successful a myriad of ways.
First, laws regarding reproductive health, gender and termination are rapidly being rewritten nationwide. In Texas and Oklahoma, those states effectively connection a bounty to anyone who reports a suspected abortion. In different states, being transgender tin result successful exclusion from organized sports. One could easy ideate a satellite successful which – if schoolhouse officials oregon coaches are expected to travel an athlete’s menstrual rhythm – immoderate younker would beryllium reported up the concatenation (accurately oregon inaccurately) for missed periods. For immoderate youth, this reporting could effect successful inappropriate and invasive gynecologic exams. For different youth, this could effect successful them and their parents being charged with a crime. And knowing astir a kid’s periods perchance puts schools successful a presumption of liability.
Second, the information of a third-party bundle strategy (such arsenic that being utilized by districts successful Florida) is often dubious. While I can’t justice the level of information peculiar bundle programme being utilized successful Florida, galore of america person previously discussed our concerns about poorly designed, poorly protected “period tracking apps.” Cyber-hacking of physics wellness records is connected the rise. Even the largest, astir security-conscious wellness attraction organizations are astatine risk, and information from reproductive wellness organizations has been specifically targeted and shared. As soon arsenic we stock menstrual information with a integer application, we indispensable besides interest astir its being accessed by those with nefarious intentions.
I uncertainty that astir schoolhouse systems are acceptable for these ineligible and information risks.
Finally, arsenic a parent of a teen (and a erstwhile precocious schoolhouse athlete, myself) I cringe astatine the thought of a manager – adjacent with the champion of intentions! – pursuing a child’s menstrual rhythm for signs of missed periods. Even successful my authorities (which protects termination arsenic healthcare, albeit with parental consent), this benignant of tracking would beryllium embarrassing astatine champion and invasive astatine worst. And my worries would beryllium acold greater if I were successful a authorities that constricted my ain and my children’s reproductive rights.
I americium gladsome that Palm Beach County has reconsidered this unsafe argumentation and asked that questions about menstrual past beryllium removed from Florida’s pre-sports valuation form. Here’s hoping the Florida High School Athletic Association listens and does what’s close for the involvement of kids, parents, coaches and schools.
English (US)