Supreme Court: Is India on the cusp of legalising same sex marriage?

On Tuesday, India's Supreme Court volition commencement proceeding last arguments connected a fig of petitions seeking to legalise same-sex marriage. The tribunal has said the proceeding volition beryllium "livestreamed successful nationalist interest".

With aforesaid enactment couples and LGBTQ+ activists hoping for a judgement successful their favour and the authorities and spiritual leaders powerfully opposing aforesaid enactment union, the statement is expected to beryllium a lively one.

Among those keenly watching the proceedings would beryllium Dr Kavita Arora and Ankita Khanna, a aforesaid enactment mates who've been waiting for years to necktie the knot.

For Kavita and Ankita, it wasn't emotion astatine archetypal sight. The women archetypal became co-workers, past friends, and past came love.

Their families and friends readily accepted their relationship, but 17 years aft they met and much than a decennary aft they started surviving together, the intelligence wellness professionals accidental they are incapable to wed - "something astir couples aspire to".

The 2 are among astir a twelve and a fractional couples who person petitioned the Supreme Court to let aforesaid enactment matrimony successful India. At slightest 3 of the petitions person been filed by couples who are raising children together.

Chief Justice DY Chandrachud has called it a substance of "seminal importance" and acceptable up a five-judge law seat - which deals with important questions of instrumentality - to regularisation connected it.

The statement is important successful a state which is location to an estimated tens of millions of LGBTQ+ people. In 2012, the Indian authorities enactment their colonisation astatine 2.5 million, but calculations utilizing planetary estimates judge it to beryllium astatine slightest 10% of the full colonisation - oregon more than 135 million.

Over the years, acceptance of homosexuality has besides grown successful India. A Pew survey successful 2020 had 37% radical saying it should beryllium accepted - an summation of 22% from 15% successful 2014, the archetypal clip the question was asked successful the country.

But contempt the change, attitudes to enactment and sexuality stay mostly blimpish and activists accidental astir LGBTQ+ radical are acrophobic to travel out, adjacent to their friends and family, and attacks connected aforesaid enactment couples routinely marque headlines.

So a batch of attraction is focussed connected what happens successful the apical tribunal successful the coming days - a favourable determination volition marque India the 35th state successful the satellite to legalise aforesaid enactment union and acceptable disconnected momentous changes successful society. A batch of different laws, specified arsenic those governing adoption, divorcement and inheritance, volition besides person to beryllium rejigged.

Ankita and Kavita accidental they anticipation it volition happen, due to the fact that that volition marque it imaginable for them to marry.

Ankita, a therapist, and Kavita, a psychiatrist, unneurotic tally a session that works with children and young adults with intelligence wellness issues and learning disabilities.

On 23 September 2020, they applied to get married.

"We were astatine that signifier successful our narration wherever we were reasoning astir marriage. Also, we were bushed of warring the strategy each clip we wanted thing done - specified arsenic get a associated slope relationship oregon a wellness security policy, ain a location together, oregon constitute a will."

One incidental that proved "a catalyst" was erstwhile Ankita's parent needed an exigency country but Kavita, who had accompanied her to the hospital, says she couldn't motion the consent signifier "because I couldn't accidental I was her daughter, nor could I accidental I was her daughter-in-law".

But connected 30 September, erstwhile they went to the magistrate's bureau successful their area, seeking to solemnise their marriage, they were turned away.

The mates past petitioned the Delhi precocious court, seeking legalisation of aforesaid enactment matrimony - and a absorption to the authorities to registry their wedding.

After a fig of akin petitions were filed by same-sex couples successful the Supreme Court and crossed precocious courts successful India, the apical tribunal successful January bunched them unneurotic and said it volition deliberate the "important" issue.

In their petition, filed done elder lawyer Menaka Guruswamy, Ankita and Kavita accidental "what we question is not the close to beryllium near alone, but the close to beryllium acknowledged arsenic equals."

The Indian constitution, their petition adds, gives each citizens the close to wed a idiosyncratic of their prime and prohibits favoritism connected the ground of intersexual predisposition and their petition should beryllium allowed since "constitutional morality is supra societal morality".

"I'm precise optimistic and person large religion successful the judiciary," Ms Guruswamy, whose squad is representing six same-sex national cases successful court, told the BBC.

Some of her optimism travel from speechmaking the December 2018 judgement that decriminalised cheery sex - "the happening that struck maine astir was that the tribunal emphasised the close to prime of spouse and that makes maine precise optimistic", she said.

While striking down the colonial-era law, the judges besides said that "history owed an apology to LGBT radical and their families for the ignominy and ostracism they person faced".

But considering the absorption to aforesaid enactment matrimony from the authorities and spiritual leaders, Ms Guruswamy has a pugnacious combat connected her hands.

The Indian authorities has urged the apical tribunal to cull the petitions, saying that a matrimony could instrumentality spot lone betwixt a antheral and a pistillate who are heterosexual.

"Living unneurotic arsenic partners and intersexual relationships by aforesaid enactment individuals ... are not comparable with the Indian household portion conception of a husband, a woman and children," the instrumentality ministry argued successful a filing successful the court.

It added that the tribunal cannot beryllium asked "to alteration the full legislative argumentation of the state profoundly embedded successful spiritual and societal norms" and that substance should beryllium near to beryllium debated successful the parliament.

In a uncommon amusement of unity, leaders from each of India's main religions - Hindu, Muslim, Jain, Sikh and Christian - also opposed aforesaid enactment union, with respective of them insisting that matrimony "is for procreation, not recreation".

And past month, 21 retired precocious tribunal judges besides weighed successful connected the subject. Legalisation of same-sex matrimony would person a "devastating interaction connected children, household and society", they wrote successful an unfastened letter.

The judges added that allowing same-sex matrimony could summation incidence of HIV-Aids successful India and expressed interest that it could "negatively impact the intelligence and affectional improvement of children raised by same-sex couples".

But past weekend, the petitioners received a large boost erstwhile Indian Psychiatric Society (IPS) - the country's starring intelligence wellness radical which represents much than 7,000 psychiatrists - issued a connection successful their support.

"Homosexuality is not a disease," the IPS said successful a statement, adding that favoritism against LGBTQ+ radical could "lead to intelligence wellness issues successful them".

The IPS connection carries immoderate heft - successful 2018, the organisation had released a akin connection supporting decriminalising cheery enactment and the Supreme Court had referred to it successful their judgement.

I inquire Ankita and Kavita what they deliberation volition hap successful court?

"We cognize that the constitution was framed to let for equality and diverseness and our religion successful judiciary and constitution is unwavering," says Ankita.

Adds Kavita: "We knew determination would beryllium opposition, we knew this wasn't going to beryllium a cakewalk. But we chose to undertake this journey, this is what we started, let's spot wherever it takes us."

BBC News India is present connected YouTube. Click to subscribe and ticker our documentaries, explainers and features.