TANF needs more accountability and better funding - Niskanen Center

Former Hall of Fame backmost Brett Favre has been successful the quality for potentially receiving implicit $1 cardinal from Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) funds meant to assistance low-income families successful Mississippi. The Favre ungraded is conscionable the astir caller of a long bid of scandals surrounding Mississippi’s misuse of payment funds. 

While immoderate person gleefully applied the aforesaid “welfare queen” statement to Favre arsenic was affixed to Linda Taylor 5 decades ago, the Washington Post editorial board utilized the juncture to constituent retired immoderate of the broader structural issues that person plagued national TANF backing since the 1996 payment reforms.

The committee touched connected 2 chiseled issues – 1 regarding national oversight and 1 astir national enactment — that are worthy exploring further.

“The nutrient determination is terrible…”

The Post editorial committee rightly points retired that lax oversight and unclear standards from the national authorities led to a concern wherever national TANF grants person “degenerated into an opaque slush money for states.” A comparatively tiny proportionality of TANF funds really scope families arsenic basal currency assistance. The remainder of the funds are siphoned disconnected for different social-policy goals. Between 1997 and 2020, the stock of funds utilized for currency assistance plummeted from 71 percent to 22 percent. 

Some progressives constituent to spending connected Republican-favored initiatives to foster matrimony oregon situation gestation centers — or, successful Favre’s case, plain aged grift — arsenic examples of wherefore we person seen a diminution successful currency assistance. The world is that lone a tiny proportionality of TANF dollars are utilized for these ends.  

Recent probe from Zach Parolin highlights trends successful authorities spending priorities implicit time. He finds that spending connected programs to facilitate employment and different services has overtaken currency assistance arsenic a proportionality of full TANF spending. The erstwhile includes enactment subsidies, education/training, kid attraction assistance, and refundable taxation credits. The second class is comprised of assorted types of societal services spending. Spending connected programs to discourage lone motherhood has accrued but typically lone makes up little than 7 percent of full spending. 

Figure 1. TANF spending by class 1997-2014

Source: Socio-Economic Review

The Favre ungraded has gained attraction due to the fact that it’s an egregious maltreatment of TANF funds. But earlier this caller play of grift, TANF backing successful Mississippi was astir apt to beryllium siphoned disconnected for what astir would see tenable ends similar enactment subsidies, education/training, and kid care. 

“…and the portions are truthful small”

The editorial committee besides correctly points retired that national backing has shrunk considerably implicit time. Because the worth of the artifact assistance is not indexed for inflation, it has mislaid astir 40 percent of its existent worth since 1997. This erosion is compounded by the information that it is not adjusted for colonisation size either, leaving less dollars to screen much children implicit time. 

These issues are particularly problematic for Mississippi due to the fact that of the mode Congress initially structured the TANF artifact assistance backmost successful 1996. As I person explained successful “Rich State, Poor State,” authorities allocations for the caller artifact assistance are based connected an older matching look that efficaciously advantaged affluent states implicit mediocre states. All states whitethorn person seen their national TANF assistance shrink implicit time, but states similar Mississippi started from a importantly little baseline. 

Figure 2. Spending per kid map

Source: Data Wrapper

As a effect of these shifts, Mississippi receives a fraction of the national backing per kid that affluent states person from the aforesaid artifact grant. New York, which is doubly arsenic affluent arsenic Mississippi, receives astir 5 times arsenic overmuch per child. The disparity is truthful important that adjacent if Mississippi spent the entirety of its national TANF backing connected currency assistance, it would inactive not beryllium capable to walk arsenic overmuch per kid arsenic New York does now.  

Time for a transpartisan woody connected TANF?

As with past payment scandals, the archetypal absorption connected the close volition beryllium to get pugnacious connected waste, fraud, and maltreatment successful the program, portion those connected the near volition telephone for much resources. 

Among Republicans, the JOBS Act would instrumentality important archetypal steps to summation accountability by limiting authorities spending connected halfway basal and employment assistance to nary little than 25 percent of full spending. In addition, programs would beryllium constricted to serving families making nary much than 200 percent of the national poorness line. The measure would besides overhaul reporting requirements, but it does thing to reverse the artifact grant’s erosion oregon inequitable allocation. 

Among Democrats, the absorption has been connected increasing the worth of the artifact grants without afloat addressing allocation issues oregon backing leakages to questionable programs. Increasing backing without tackling the root of currency assistance crowd-out is simply a look for disaster. 

Effective betterment volition necessitate tackling the deficiency of accountability successful authorities spending arsenic good arsenic the shrinking backing and inequities successful the allocation of TANF funds crossed states. Providing enactment for our astir susceptible families is excessively important to let partisan stalemates to basal successful the mode of fixing TANF.

Photo credit: iStock