The FTC’s cases against Meta are chasing Facebook’s ghost - Fortune

Given the clip and resources the committee is pouring into the case, you’d expect Meta to beryllium crushing the contention similar an unstoppable machine.

However, Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg precocious announced the company’s steepest circular of layoffs ever, letting spell 13% of the company’s staff, amidst a unreserved of painful, wide publicized hiring freezes and layoffs across the tech sector. 

Meta has shed 70% of its worth this year, totaling implicit $730 cardinal successful marketplace headdress lost. It’s a testament to however challenging it is to support the rod presumption successful a abstraction arsenic fickle arsenic societal networking, particularly erstwhile it comes to caller generations of customers. It’s hard to marque a coagulated lawsuit for Meta’s alleged “market dominance” successful this context, arsenic the FTC seeks to bash successful its suit.

It seems that regulators successful Washington are much focused than ever connected chasing ephemeral claims of anti-competitive behaviour by tech companies–including Meta–at a clip erstwhile galore tech firms are already warring to survive. The FTC is hunting for ghosts and ignoring the realities of the marketplace and user behavior.

The FTC’s dual mandate requires the bureau to some beforehand contention and support consumers from unfair concern practices. And portion this ngo could not beryllium much important astatine this time, the agency’s 2 abstracted cases against Meta, and its crusade against Big Tech, neglect to execute these goals.

Instead of making straightforward cases against evident atrocious actors, the FTC appears to beryllium contorting itself to find a crushed to spell aft Meta. It already has a pending case that challenges Meta’s acquisitions of Whatsapp and Instagram, which day backmost 8 and 10 years ago, respectively.

However, the unchecked emergence of TikTok, which brings with it immense privateness risks arsenic China tin reportedly collect Americans’ data, shows however poorly the FTC’s suit has aged.

In its lawsuit against Meta’s acquisition of Within Unlimited, the committee has already had to drop its claim that Meta adjacent competes with Within. Instead, it’s had to treble down connected a perceived imaginable contention assertion that has been historically unsuccessful successful court.

Merely one percent of voters prioritize tech regularisation arsenic a nationalist argumentation contented they privation Congress to tackle, according to our pre-midterm polling. And when we asked voters astir regulatory priorities for tech, their absorption was connected information privateness and security–not contention and antitrust.

Regulators person a work to wage attraction to what’s happening successful the marketplace and who they’re targeting. With these lawsuits, the FTC is warring an old, imagined mentation of Facebook, not today’s Meta that’s successful a competitory dogfight for its aboriginal survival.

The FTC’s pursuit of Meta volition yet constrain innovation and supply nary benefits to consumers–not to notation that it’s a mediocre usage of the agency’s finite resources. The FTC should crook its absorption to battling practices that effect successful existent user harm alternatively of going aft companies whose aboriginal maturation is acold from assured.

As the tech manufacture reckons with this turning point, regulators indispensable too. The bureau would beryllium amended disconnected focusing its efforts connected pursuing targeted policies that code the user problems that really request solving, alternatively than swiping astatine ghosts.

Adam Kovacevich is the laminitis and CEO of the Chamber of Progress, a tech manufacture argumentation conjugation promoting technology’s progressive future. Meta is 1 of the Chamber of Progress’ firm partners.

The opinions expressed successful Fortune.com commentary pieces are solely the views of their authors and bash not needfully bespeak the opinions and beliefs of Fortune.

More must-read commentary published by Fortune:

• Will the U.S. and Europe descent into recession successful 2023? Here’s however to look retired erstwhile economical outlooks don’t
• Biden crowned world energy czar as diplomacy triumphs implicit Putin’s tantrums
• Are you wagering wealth connected the World Cup? Sports betting is taking America by storm–and a 3rd of young men are hooked
• Could Kanye West be placed nether Kim Kardashian’s conservatorship?