Train cancellations: 'Travelling to work can cost me more than I earn'

Vet Jenna Blackburn's accustomed commute is Chester to Manchester, changing astatine Warrington, often connected Northern.

But she regularly gets stuck successful Warrington erstwhile trains are delayed oregon cancelled and has to get a taxi home.

She doesn't thrust and connected onslaught days determination were nary trains running. She said she took taxis to and from enactment which outgo her much than £160.

She is 1 of galore facing disruption, with bid cancellations astatine the highest level since records began successful 2015.

Newly released information from the Office of Road and Rail shows 3.8% of trains successful Great Britain person been cancelled successful the twelvemonth up to 12 November - oregon 1 successful each 26.

"At slightest 4 times this twelvemonth I've spent much connected getting present and backmost than I person really earnt that day," Ms Blackburn said.

"On a semi-regular ground I'm getting location astatine 9 o'clock astatine night," she added. "Delay repay is astir £6. It'll wage a 4th of your bid summons truthful it doesn't screen anything."

Ms Blackburn said a taxi location from Warrington to Chester usually costs betwixt £30 and £40, depending connected the time. But connected onslaught days taxi prices are higher.

"Strikes are a nightmare due to the fact that Chester presumption fundamentally conscionable shuts down. This twelvemonth I've had to walk £160 1 time conscionable to get present due to the fact that it was a engaged time for taxis truthful it was £160 present and back."

She added: "Over this twelvemonth I've had to person hotels due to the fact that I've not been capable to get location connected the past bid due to the fact that it's been cancelled and tons of taxis."

"Financially it's a lot," she said. "You're coming to enactment to marque wealth and you tin walk much than your day's wage to get home."

"Emotionally it's exhausting, to perpetually person to look astatine the bid times each azygous day. And anticipation I'm not going to beryllium stranded," she said.

When trains are running, Ms Blackburn said they are often crowded and strikes person added other accent and expense.

The persistent disruption successful caller months has prompted outcry from commuters, leisure travellers, politicians and concern groups, peculiarly successful the North of England.

The Transport Secretary Mark Harper is owed to conscionable a radical of mayors successful the portion connected Wednesday to sermon the situation.

Cancellations alteration crossed the country.

Avanti West Coast, which operates trains betwixt London and Birmingham, Manchester, North Wales and Scotland, had the highest proportionality of cancellations, astatine 8%.

Second highest was Govia Thameslink Railway - which runs Southern, Thameslink, Great Northern and Gatwick Express - astatine 6.5%.

Third was TransPennine Express, with 5.8% of trains cancelled.

These figures bespeak on-the-day cancellations.

They won't see planned onslaught timetables, oregon the database of beforehand cancellations TransPennine Express releases connected a regular basis.

In total, 520,853 services were scheduled crossed Great Britain betwixt 16 October and 12 November, 15% little than the aforesaid clip successful 2019.

Passenger numbers are presently lone astir 80% of pre-Covid levels - though they person been higher astatine immoderate points recently.

Avanti has travel successful for peculiar disapproval for terrible disruption successful July, and past slashing its timetable successful August. It said the main crushed was drivers abruptly stopped volunteering to enactment connected their remainder days.

In October, Avanti's declaration was extended for lone six months. The authorities said it indispensable "drastically improve".

The bid relation has apologised for the "enormous magnitude of vexation and inconvenience". It is inactive rebuilding services arsenic much drivers are trained up, and says it's focused connected restoring a afloat timetable successful December.

TransPennine has besides travel nether the spotlight for mediocre services, though it insists cancellation numbers person been reducing.

Author and railway expert Christian Wolmar said the railways were successful the "worst state" helium had seen successful 25 years of penning astir them.

Earlier this period I spoke to Steve Montgomery, the brag of First Rail; genitor of some TransPennine Express and Avanti.

He apologised for show not being bully enough, and insisted the operators bash employment capable bid drivers; thing their national Aslef disputes.

Mr Montgomery's mentation was that Covid straight caused a backlog of operator training, which tin instrumentality up to 18 months, and unit sickness levels are high.

Added to this, reliance connected drivers agreeing to enactment connected days disconnected - which has been communal successful the manufacture for decades - has near immoderate operators exposed during a play of strained concern relations.

Transpennine hasn't had a remainder time moving statement successful spot with Aslef for astir a year. It says this means little flexibility. But it says much drivers are, steadily, qualifying.

Avanti is aiming to reconstruct a afloat timetable successful mid December - without relying connected overtime.

Angie Doll, main operating serviceman of GTR, said show implicit the past twelvemonth had been affected by the interaction of Covid, short-term sickness, terrible upwind and expanding trespass incidents.

She said the relation had a program successful spot to marque improvements, and was moving with Network Rail to amended reliability. GTR besides noted issues astatine different bid companies could person a knock-on effect.

In a connection Tricia Williams, main operating serviceman of Northern, apologised for disruption, putting it down to factors "including fully-trained operator availability and the on-going concern relations issues with the commercialized unions".

These aren't the lone operators with unit problems. On Sunday, bid drivers successful Aslef stopped moving overtime astatine LNER, aft a caller vote.

Infrastructure problems play a relation too. ORR precocious said Network Rail, which oversees tracks, powerfulness lines and signals, needed to bash much to present amended performance.

But Mr Wolmar said helium believed determination was much to the caller problems, with a "perfect storm" of factors.

"Some of it is really downright mediocre management," helium said. "And that sentiment comes not conscionable from maine arsenic a railway watcher but from a batch of the elder railway radical I speech to."

During the Covid crisis, the authorities moved bid companies onto exigency contracts.

Now, astir bid operators are paid connected a performance-related fixed interest basis, and it is the government, that bears the fiscal hazard - and holds the purse strings.

Mr Wolmar believes these contracts person resulted successful little effort from managers to tally a bully service, and precocious sickness levels among unit who person gone implicit 2 years without a wage rise, are "really an look of worker dissatisfaction".

The Rail Delivery Group (RDG), which represents bid companies, said: "We wholly cull immoderate proposition that the replacement of franchises with contracts during the pandemic is adversely affecting performance."

It added that portion it was existent that the Department for Transport present pays bid operators a interest to tally bid services, that outgo was performance-related.

The RDG said the pandemic has had a semipermanent interaction connected services by reducing the fig of drivers and different unit who could beryllium trained arsenic good arsenic expanding unit absences.

It acknowledged that the nationalist quality involving 3 obstruction unions had caused terrible disruption and connected cancellations it said "the manufacture is moving hard to header with an unprecedented convergence of issues".

Meanwhile, the aboriginal of however the railway is tally is present uncertain, aft the instauration of a caller umbrella assemblage called "Great British Railways", was delayed.

Train companies are preparing to present a caller timetable connected 11 December - though RMT strikes are planned successful its archetypal week. Passengers volition beryllium hoping this alteration ushers successful much reliability.

Please see a interaction fig if you are consenting to talk to a BBC journalist. You tin besides get successful interaction successful the pursuing ways:

If you are speechmaking this leafage and can't spot the signifier you tin email america astatine HaveYourSay@bbc.co.uk. Please see your name, property and determination with immoderate submission.