The varying statements exemplify 1 of the archetypal large divergences successful sentiment betwixt Washington and Kyiv — an confederation that, for the astir part, has acted successful a swift, coordinated manner for astir 9 months to assistance Ukraine bushed backmost Russian advances. U.S. officials are downplaying the differences, but the anticipation that the warfare volition proceed done the wintertime means much specified fractures could look — and Moscow could exploit them.
The disorder spawned by the rocket blast was a “really important trial run” for the United States, its NATO allies and Ukraine, said Heather Conley, a erstwhile State Department authoritative with expertise successful Europe.
“I deliberation we each learned a beauteous invaluable acquisition successful [that] you cannot accidental thing close disconnected the bat until you recognize what it is … due to the fact that the stakes are truthful precocious close now,” said Conley, present president of the German Marshall Fund of the United States. Overall, Conley said, astir countries progressive did well, but “you tin archer we inactive person enactment to do.”
The rocket deed southeastern Poland connected Tuesday conscionable arsenic Russia had ramped up its rocket attacks connected Ukraine. The incidental raised planetary alarms fixed that Poland is successful NATO and a Russian onslaught connected its ungraded could person prompted a effect by the subject alliance.
Zelenskyy and immoderate of his aides rapidly blamed the Kremlin. But implicit the adjacent 24 hours, U.S., NATO and Polish leaders said grounds suggested the onslaught successful Poland apt originated from a Ukrainian aerial defence rocket trying to thwart a Russian strike.
On Wednesday, Zelenskyy said his subject leaders had assured him Russia was the root of the missile. “I person nary uncertainty that it was not our rocket oregon not our rocket strike,” helium said. President Joe Biden, upon returning aboriginal Thursday greeting from a travel to Asia for the G-20 summit, disputed Zelenskyy’s comments, saying “that’s not the evidence.”
Zelenskyy’s connection prompted apical U.S. officials to scope retired to NATO allies connected Wednesday, saying that the U.S. believed the rocket appeared to beryllium from Ukraine and Russian-made, according to 2 Western officials acquainted with the conversations. They, similar others quoted, requested anonymity to talk much freely astir delicate nationalist information matters.
U.S. quality supports the assertion that a Ukrainian missile, a long-range surface-to-air rocket fired from the S-300 rocket defence system, appears to person caused the detonation successful Poland, the 2 radical said.
U.S. quality agencies person not commented. But the U.S. has publically said that it believes the rocket is apt from Ukraine. A spokesperson for the National Security Council, reiterating an earlier statement, said the medication has not seen thing that contradicts Poland’s appraisal that the detonation was astir apt the effect of a Ukrainian aerial defence missile.
CIA Director William Burns met with Polish President Andrzej Duda connected Wednesday and discussed the detonation successful Poland, a U.S. authoritative said, without providing details oregon the determination of the meeting. The authoritative added that Burns told Duda the U.S. was committed to continuing to supply enactment to Ukraine. The gathering had been scheduled earlier the rocket strike, the authoritative said.
As of Wednesday evening, Ukrainian officials, including those successful Zelenskyy’s office, were unconvinced and expressed to immoderate of their European counterparts that they wanted to spot factual grounds that the rocket was Ukrainian.
“He is going to request a batch of convincing,” 1 of the Western officials said of Zelenskyy. “He inactive has not seen the evidence.”
By Thursday, Zelenskyy had somewhat adjusted his position, telling the Bloomberg New Economy Forum successful Singapore: “I don’t cognize 100 percent – I deliberation the satellite besides doesn’t 100 percent cognize what happened.” He said his subject aides had told him, based connected visuals of the blast site, that it could not person been caused solely by a Ukrainian anti-missile projectile.
Some Western leaders person sought to usage the infinitesimal to reason that the eventual blasted inactive falls connected Russia, which launched its full-scale penetration of Ukraine successful February. Had Moscow not gone up with its unprovoked war, Ukraine wouldn’t beryllium utilizing a rocket defence strategy to statesman with, U.S., NATO and different officials person said.
“Russia launched different barrage of missiles against Ukraine specifically intended to people Ukraine’s civilian infrastructure,” Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin said Wednesday. “This tragic and troubling incidental is yet different reminder of the recklessness of Russia’s warfare of choice.”
Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-N.H.), who leads the Senate Foreign Relations Committee’s Europe panel, said Russia was inactive astatine responsibility careless of who owned the missile. “This would not person happened without Russia’s unprovoked, atrocious warfare successful Ukraine. Regardless of whose rocket it was, Russia is yet astatine fault,” she said.
For its part, the Kremlin has taken umbrage astatine initially being blamed for the Poland blast. “We spot this mayhem arsenic a deliberate effort made arsenic portion of a systematic anti-Russia run conducted by the West astir Ukraine,” the Russian Foreign Ministry said successful a statement.
Secretary of State Antony Blinken connected Thursday did not straight reply a newsman who asked him astir Zelenskyy’s reliability. But he said helium and different medication officials are successful touch with Ukrainian counterparts and that everyone is waiting for Poland to decorativeness its probe.
“We besides person among each of america — Ukraine, Poland, the United States, our NATO allies, G7 partners — a committedness to travel the facts,” Blinken said.
The warfare is present entering what’s expected to beryllium a brutal winter, and immoderate subject leaders foretell that portion the warring volition proceed to beryllium heavy, neither broadside volition marque important gains fixed the upwind conditions. The momentum appears to beryllium with Ukraine, which has pushed Russia retired of ample tracts of its territory, including astir precocious the Kherson area. But Kyiv volition request to proceed to beryllium resupplied with arms and humanitarian assistance to support immoderate borderline it has gained.
The diplomatic wrangling implicit the rocket onslaught is lone the latest motion of hostility implicit messaging astir the war.
Gen. Mark Milley, the seat of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, connected Wednesday reiterated his telephone for Ukraine to usage its existent battlefield leverage to prosecute bid negotiations with Russia. Biden and nationalist information advisor Jake Sullivan person said repeatedly it is up to Ukraine to determine erstwhile it wants to negotiate.
Milley argues that Kyiv cannot yet propulsion Russia wholly retired of its territory, contempt Zelenskyy’s stated goals and that it’s champion to negociate astatine a infinitesimal of strength.
It’s an statement with immoderate merit, erstwhile U.S. officials and analysts say, particularly erstwhile considering Russia’s beardown grip connected the Crimea portion and its undiminished capableness to churn retired monolithic amounts of munitions to propulsion into the fight. Still, galore of those aforesaid radical note, U.S. officials person connected much than juncture underestimated the Ukrainian military’s abilities, portion overestimating that of the Russians.
But Zelenskyy is nether tremendous unit from his ain radical not to concede an inch of ungraded to Moscow, particularly aft grounds has emerged of Russian atrocities against Ukrainian civilians. And, for present astatine least, Russian person Vladimir Putin appears unwilling to prosecute successful negotiations.
Throughout the conflict, the United States has maintained diplomatic contacts with Russian officials astatine virtually each levels, including done its embassy successful Moscow and Sullivan. The U.S.-Russian discussions interaction connected aggregate topics, including Americans detained successful Russia and the Kremlin’s occasional atomic threats.
Those diplomatic connections could beryllium captious implicit clip if and erstwhile the Ukrainians and Russians determine they are acceptable to negotiate. But there’s nary existent U.S.-Russian backchannel focused connected specified negotiations, an medication authoritative acquainted with the contented said.
Biden himself has repeatedly said it’s up to Kyiv to determine erstwhile immoderate bid talks should spell forward. “We are not going to prosecute successful immoderate negotiation. There’s nary — thing astir Ukraine without Ukraine,” the president said portion successful Bali, Indonesia, this week. “This is simply a determination Ukraine has to make.”
One diplomat from a NATO state pointed to the astir 100 Russian missiles fired astatine Ukrainian civilian targets connected Tuesday — portion Burns was successful Kyiv — arsenic impervious that the Kremlin isn’t funny successful talking peace. In caller comments, Sullivan pointed to Russia’s claims that it had annexed immoderate Ukrainian territory arsenic additional grounds of a deficiency of seriousness astir bid connected the Kremlin’s part.
“There’s a batch of signaling astir bid talks,” Estonian Permanent Secretary of the Ministry of Defense Kusti Salm told reporters successful a virtual roundtable Thursday. At the moment, specified signaling is “an avenue with nary affirmative result … from the Ukrainian perspective, particularly if the interim oregon immoderate different signifier of bid colony would mean territorial concessions, it would pb the state into terrible difficulties.”
Lara Seligman and Alexander Ward contributed to this report.
English (US)