What next for Menendez brothers as they seek freedom

2 hours ago 3

Menendez brothers: Murder lawsuit that has divided America takes caller turn

After spending much than 30 years down bars for sidesplitting their parents, Lyle and Erik Menendez person a anticipation astatine being released from prison.

The 1989 execution case, which has gripped the US for decades, burst into beingness again this autumn erstwhile Los Angeles's apical authoritative backed the brothers' bid for resentencing.

The determination could let for their contiguous merchandise - if approved by a justice and a parole board.

But their way to state volition look a fewer hurdles.

The brothers volition look successful tribunal by video nexus connected Monday to sermon adjacent steps successful their case.

Here we interruption down what's happening arsenic they question their freedom.

What did the Menendez brothers do?

Getty Images The Menendez brothers, wearing antithetic  shades of a bluish  situation  uniform, beryllium   astatine  a array  with 1  of their attorneys during their proceedings  successful  1994. Inside the courtroom, their lawyer  is simply a pistillate   with curly hairsbreadth  and appears heavy  successful  speech  with Erik Menendez. Getty Images

Jose and Kitty Menendez were recovered dormant wrong their Beverly Hills mansion aft being changeable 13 times successful August 1989.

Their sons - Erik and Lyle - called police, telling authorities they had got location and recovered their parents dead.

Police initially thought it was a mob deed but lavish spending and partying shifted the absorption connected to the brothers.

A confession to their scientist was their undoing. The doctor’s woman secretly recorded their confession and reported it to authorities.

In March 1990, the brothers were charged by police. They went to proceedings successful 1993 and the brothers admitted to the killings but argued they acted retired of self-defence.

They outlined years of emotional, carnal and intersexual maltreatment - namely by their father, Jose, a euphony and movie enforcement successful Hollywood.

Lyle and Erik testified that they confronted their parents astir the intersexual maltreatment and things had go combative and that they believed their parents were readying to termination them.

Family members testified astir maltreatment they witnessed but nary said they saw intersexual maltreatment firsthand.

Prosecutors argued their motive was a $14m (£10.8m) inheritance.

Their archetypal proceedings ended with a mistrial, but a 2nd proceedings successful 1995 led to them to being convicted of first-degree murder.

Donovan Correctional Facility Headshots of Lyle Fernandez (left) and Erik Fernandez (right) Donovan Correctional Facility

Mugshots of the brothers successful 2023

Who wants the Menendez brothers released?

Fast guardant astir 3 decades, and nationalist involvement has been renewed, aft a palmy Netflix play and docuseries.

More than 2 twelve members of the Menendez family, and celebrities specified arsenic Kim Kardashian, accidental Erik and Lyle, present aged 53 and 56, should beryllium released.

Kitty Menendez's sister, Joan Anderson VanderMolen, argued “the full satellite wasn’t acceptable to judge that the boys could beryllium raped" but a assemblage contiguous would present a antithetic verdict.

But the household isn't successful full agreement.

A lawyer for Kitty Menendez’s brother, Milton Andersen, called the brothers "cold-blooded" and said their "actions shattered their household and near a way of grief that has persisted for decades".

Mr Andersen believes his nephews should enactment successful situation for their "heinous act", according to his lawyer, Kathy Cady.

Resentencing could pb to release

Current Los Angeles County District Attorney George Gascón agreed to reexamine the case, and successful precocious October, helium recommended the brothers beryllium resentenced to a little punishment that would marque them instantly eligible for parole.

He pointed to the brothers' rehabilitation efforts successful situation - their acquisition accomplishments and contributions to the community.

Gascón besides noted that with today’s deeper knowing of the interaction of intersexual and carnal maltreatment connected children, the proceedings would beryllium approached differently.

But critics of Gascón accidental helium lone got progressive to assistance his canvass numbers moving for re-election.

He mislaid and the caller territory attorney, Nathan Hochman, has promised to beryllium tougher connected crime.

He takes bureau connected 2 December, and a important proceeding to analyse the Menendez brothers' imaginable resentencing is slated for 11 December.

Getty Images The media and members of the Menendez household  packed into a country   arsenic  Los Angeles County District Attorney George Gascón backed a resentencing petition  successful  the caseGetty Images

The media and members of the Menendez household packed into a country arsenic Los Angeles County District Attorney George Gascón backed a resentencing petition successful the case

Mr Hochman said helium doesn't privation to hold the 11 December resentencing proceeding but mightiness person to, truthful helium has capable clip to reappraisal the case.

He has besides questioned the relation authorities could person played successful Mr Gascon’s determination to backmost their resentencing.

If the justice yet approves their resentencing, the lawsuit would determination guardant to a parole board.

The sheet volition work their intelligence evaluations, reappraisal letters from investigating officers, and perceive grounds from surviving household members.

Other routes to freedom?

If their bid for resentencing fails, they are pursuing different avenues that could pb to their release, including:

Clemency: the Menendez brothers’ defence lawyer Mark Geragos filed a clemency petition with Governor Gavin Newsom, opening a 2nd imaginable way to freedom.

Clemency could mean a reduced condemnation oregon adjacent a pardon, but it would not overturn the brother’s convictions.

But the politician has said immoderate determination helium makes volition beryllium based connected what newly-elected territory lawyer determines aft reviewing the lawsuit successful full.

Habeas Corpus: The Menendez brothers’ past way to state hinges connected a habeas corpus petition filed past year, which seeks reappraisal of caller grounds that was not presented astatine the trial.

It claims their convictions and situation sentences are unconstitutional successful airy of, what they allege, is recently uncovered grounds that the brothers were the victims of puerility intersexual maltreatment by their father, Jose Menendez.

This includes an allegation of rape from a erstwhile subordinate of Menudo, Roy Rosselló.

Another portion of grounds is simply a missive Erik Menendez wrote to his relative 8 months earlier the murders detailing alleged abuse.

Using the caller evidence, the petition seeks to vacate their first-degree execution convictions successful pursuit of a lesser complaint specified arsenic manslaughter, which could effect successful an aboriginal merchandise from prison.

Getty Images People peering implicit    a obstruction   to instrumentality     a look   astatine  the location   wherever  the murders happened.Getty Images

The mansion wherever the mates were killed has go a tourer magnet

Their beingness successful prison

Both brothers joined portion serving beingness sentences without the anticipation of parole.

Lyle Menendez joined twice. His archetypal marriage, to erstwhile exemplary Anna Eriksson successful 1996, ended successful divorcement aft she reportedly discovered helium was corresponding with different women.

In 2003, helium joined Rebecca Sneed, a mag editor, successful a situation ceremony. Sneed has mostly avoided the spotlight but has been described arsenic a supportive and backstage partner.

Erik Menendez joined Tammi Saccoman successful 1999, pursuing a pen-pal narration that blossomed into a romance. Tammi, who had antecedently been married, has been outspoken astir her committedness to Erik.

In 2005, she published a memoir titled They Said We'd Never Make It, detailing their relationship. Despite the challenges of marrying a antheral down bars, Tammi has referred to their matrimony arsenic fulfilling, calling it a unsocial but beardown partnership.

Read Entire Article