What the Christian McCaffrey trade means for 49ers, Panthers: Answering biggest questions

2 years ago 44

The San Francisco 49ers person mostly watched arsenic the NFC West part rival Los Angeles Rams person repeatedly swung for the fences to effort to triumph the Super Bowl. That attack worked for the Rams past year. The Niners judge it's their turn, which is wherefore they pulled disconnected a stunning commercialized for moving backmost Christian McCaffrey precocious Thursday night.

The Niners sent second-, third- and fourth-round picks successful 2023 and a fifth-round prime successful 2024 to the Carolina Panthers for McCaffrey successful hopes helium tin assistance jump-start a sagging offense.

Through the archetypal six weeks, the 49ers person been plagued by injuries each implicit the roster and their discourtesy hasn't played adjacent to the level of their ascendant defense.

Coach Kyle Shanahan doesn't privation a repetition of 2019, erstwhile the Niners wasted an elite defence arsenic the discourtesy couldn't adjacent retired the Super Bowl against the Kansas City Chiefs.

Put simply: San Francisco believes it is successful a title model and trading for McCaffrey sends that connection large and wide to the remainder of the league.

How volition McCaffrey acceptable into the 49ers offense?

This should beryllium comparatively seamless for McCaffrey, who has plentifulness of acquisition operating successful an extracurricular zone-heavy strategy and brings the benignant of versatility that volition let Shanahan to premix and lucifer him with the team's skill-position options. And marque nary mistake, portion McCaffrey volition beryllium the team's No. 1 enactment astatine moving back, Shanahan volition usage him successful the walk crippled plentifulness and make much headaches for defenses who present person to support way of him and the likes of receivers Deebo Samuel and Brandon Aiyuk and choky extremity George Kittle. -- Nick Wagoner


Did the 49ers springiness up excessively much?

On paper, it seems similar it. But erstwhile you marque an all-in determination similar this, there's nary terms that's excessively precocious if it pays off. The hazard is obvious: McCaffrey has missed 23 games successful the past 2 seasons and he's joining a squad that is consistently snakebit by injury. And portion the Niners person a mates of third-round compensatory picks, they're fundamentally punting connected the 2023 NFL draft. Adding young, cost-effective players is important for a squad that has truthful overmuch high-priced endowment and is readying to wage antiaircraft extremity Nick Bosa an tremendous magnitude of wealth this offseason. But if McCaffrey, who is nether declaration done 2025, is steadfast and connected the field, helium gives the 49ers 1 of the champion groups of skill-position players successful the league and the nonaccomplishment of aggregate Day 2 picks won't sting overmuch astatine all. -- Wagoner


Does adding McCaffrey enactment the 49ers implicit the apical successful a choky NFC West?

It should but that comes with the important caveat of whether the Niners and McCaffrey tin get (and stay) comparatively healthy. No squad has been much banged up than the Niners successful the archetypal six weeks and portion galore of those players are expected to return, determination are nary guarantees erstwhile it comes to health. If their wounded luck turns for the better, the Niners, who are already 2-0 successful the division, person the champion roster successful the NFC West and should beryllium capable to not lone triumph the division, but marque different heavy postseason run. -- Wagoner


After firing their manager and getting escaped of McCaffrey and Anderson, is this a implicit rebuild for the Panthers?

The Panthers whitethorn not telephone it a implicit rebuild due to the fact that the defence is successful bully signifier for adjacent season. Defensive tackle Matt Ioannidis is the lone starter not nether contract. But this is simply a implicit rebuild erstwhile you see the Panthers volition person a caller coaching staff, since Matt Rhule already has been fired, a caller quarterback, since Baker Mayfield and Sam Darnold aren't the answer, and a caller face, since McCaffrey is gone.

On apical of that, the receiver country is simply a mess. DJ Moore is the lone morganatic menace present that Robbie Anderson has been traded to the Arizona Cardinals. And nary of Carolina's choky ends are morganatic weapons. Not to notation the violative enactment ranks adjacent the bottommost of the league successful walk triumph and tally triumph rate. One could reason 2022 first-round prime Ikem Ekwonu has had increasing pains frankincense acold astatine near tackle. He mightiness beryllium amended suited for the close broadside oregon astatine guard. So telephone this what you want, but it's a rebuild. -- David Newton


How does this acceptable up interim manager Steve Wilks?

Wilks ne'er got a just shingle successful his 1 play (2018) arsenic the caput manager of the Arizona Cardinals due to the fact that helium didn't person the endowment to vie and coached with mostly an inherited staff. He has the aforesaid concern present with Carolina. And present helium loses his astir invaluable violative asset. McCaffrey was his offense, accounting for 75% of the team's yardage successful Sunday's 24-10 nonaccomplishment to the Los Angeles Rams. Wilks has to regenerate him with second-year backmost Chuba Hubbard and journeyman D'Onta Foreman.

The discourtesy is already rated past successful the NFL successful full yards and successful third-down percent and erstwhile XFL backmost PJ Walker is starting his 2nd consecutive crippled Sunday against Tampa Bay portion Baker Mayfield and Sam Darnold retrieve from ankle injuries. Owner David Tepper said Wilks would beryllium considered for the full-time occupation if helium does an exceptional occupation the remainder of this year. Instead, it appears he's been acceptable up for nonaccomplishment erstwhile again. This feels similar a full vessel to physique for the future. -- Newton


What are the declaration and headdress implications of the deal?

McCaffrey is simply a inexpensive one-year rental for San Francisco, with a $1.035-million wage acknowledgment to Carolina's offseason declaration restructure. Next twelvemonth it gets much complicated, arsenic McCaffrey is owed $11.8 million. But the 49ers don't inherit McCaffrey's signing bonus proration, which lessens his $19.5 cardinal headdress deed successful 2023 by respective million. This is each manageable, but inactive steep for a moving back. -- Jeremy Fowler


What different teams were progressive successful talks?

Several contenders astatine slightest made the call, but arsenic of midweek talks were dilatory to develop. Despite hype astir their interest, I ne'er got the consciousness the Buffalo Bills were all-in. Teams I've talked to believed the Rams and Denver Broncos were progressive to immoderate grade but unwilling to scope the terms constituent the 49ers ended up paying. -- Fowler

Read Entire Article