Who has the NLCS edge? Preview, predictions for Padres-Phillies

1 year ago 51

Well, excuse the San Diego Padres and Philadelphia Phillies for crashing the party.

The 101-win Mets, with a rotation featuring Max Scherzer and Jacob deGrom and their astir wins successful a regular play since 1986? Gone from these MLB playoffs.

The 101-win Braves, trying to support their World Series title with a better, deeper squad than past season? Gone successful a blitz of Phillies power.

The all-powerful, almighty Dodgers, winners of 111 games, the astir successful the National League since 1906? Gone successful a blitz of blistering Padres fastballs.

The archetypal play with six playoff teams successful the National League proved to beryllium arsenic chaotic arsenic a strategy similar this tin let it to be. Maybe you emotion it. Maybe you loathe it. (Dodgers fans decidedly loathe it.) Padres and Phillies fans volition instrumentality it, though, arsenic their teams conscionable successful the astir improbable matchup successful National League Championship Series history. That's not an exaggeration -- this is the archetypal NLCS betwixt 2 teams with less than 90 wins. But it's not lacking successful prima power, not with Bryce Harper and Aaron Nola and Manny Machado and Juan Soto.

Also of note: The condensed playoff docket means the best-of-seven bid volition beryllium played implicit 8 days alternatively than the accustomed nine, with an disconnected time aft lone Game 2. That volition enactment a small added unit connected the pitching staffs and possibly unit the managers to excavation a small deeper than accustomed into their starting rotations.

Ahead of Game 1, David Schoenfield takes a look astatine each squad and our ESPN experts marque their picks.

Jump to ...

Phillies | Padres | Our picks


Philadelphia Phillies

Why they tin determination on: Their discourtesy took it to the Braves, scoring seven, 9 and 8 runs successful their 3 victories. In a postseason wherever generating discourtesy has been hard to impossible, the Phillies person enactment unneurotic large innings: six runs successful the ninth inning to propulsion retired Game 1 of the wild-card bid against the St. Louis Cardinals and six runs successful the 3rd inning of Game 3 of the part bid against the Braves, positive 3 different three-run innings. Of their six location runs, 3 person travel with runners connected base, including three-run homers from Rhys Hoskins and Brandon Marsh against Atlanta. Keep hitting those and you mightiness spot more bat slams.

Why they mightiness not: The bullpen is inactive a enactment successful advancement for manager Rob Thomson. Zach Eflin, who didn't commencement relieving until September and picked up his archetypal vocation prevention precocious successful the season, had archetypal ace astatine ninth-inning duties and allowed 7 hits and 4 runs successful 3 innings. Luckily, the Phillies' leads were large capable that it didn't matter, and helium did adjacent retired a 2-0 triumph implicit the Cardinals cleanly. But successful the clinching crippled against the Braves, Eflin was the setup feline to Seranthony Dominguez. Meanwhile, Jose Alvarado, who allowed conscionable 2 location runs successful the regular season, has served up 2 successful the postseason.

Who's hot: In 35 games aft returning from the injured database successful precocious August, Bryce Harper deed conscionable .227/.335/.352 with 3 location runs. But helium has 3 location runs and 3 doubles successful six playoff games, including 2 blasts of much than 400 feet. A locked-in Harper is simply a beauteous show for Phillies fans.

Who's not: Kyle Schwarber, who led the NL with 46 location runs, is 1-for-20 with 8 strikeouts successful the postseason, and 2 of his 3 walks person been intentional.

How's the defense? Still bad. Nick Castellanos made a diving drawback successful close tract successful the bottommost of the ninth to assistance sphere a 7-6 triumph successful Game 1 against the Braves, but helium and Schwarber stay large liabilities successful the outfield corners -- Castellanos is successful the 2nd percentile successful Statcast's outs supra mean and Schwarber is successful the first. Alec Bohm is simply a occupation astatine 3rd base, and successful the Phils' lone nonaccomplishment truthful far, Game 2 to the Braves, Hoskins butchered a crushed shot that led to a mates of runs.

Final thought: Eliminating the Braves successful 4 games puts the Philadelphia rotation backmost successful order: Zack Wheeler volition beryllium acceptable to commencement Game 1, Aaron Nola connected afloat remainder for Game 2 and past Ranger Suarez for Game 3. But with the anticipation of 7 games successful 8 days, that means digging into the No. 4 (Noah Syndergaard) and astir apt the No. 5 (likely Bailey Falter) starters, which volition further accent the bladed bullpen. With an disconnected time aft Game 2, Wheeler would beryllium lined up to spell successful Game 5, but Nola wouldn't beryllium connected afloat remainder until Game 7. If the bid does spell seven, though -- the Phillies volition similar their chances with Nola. -- Schoenfield


San Diego Padres

Why they tin determination on: Postseason occurrence has go much and much astir uncovering the blistery bullpen -- and manager Bob Melvin mightiness person recovered it astatine precisely the close time. Robert Suarez, the 31-year-old rookie who spent his vocation successful Mexico and Japan earlier signing with the Padres, has tossed six scoreless innings successful the postseason, topping retired astatine 101.5 mph. Veteran Luis Garcia has deed 101 mph successful the postseason. Tim Hill tin beryllium a pugnacious matchup for left-handed hitters. Most importantly, person Josh Hader has rediscovered his mojo aft a fewer horrific blowups earlier successful the play with the Brewers and Padres (including a six-run outing successful precocious August). He has allowed conscionable 1 deed successful 4 1/3 scoreless innings successful the postseason and topped retired astatine 100.8 mph. If you're going to bushed the Padres' bullpen, you amended beryllium capable to deed immoderate high-octane heat.

Why they mightiness not: You request to deed location runs to triumph successful the postseason. So far, the Padres -- who ranked conscionable 12th successful the NL successful location runs successful the regular play -- person done that, hitting 9 successful 7 games. But immoderate of those person travel from astonishing sources, mostly notably 3 from Trent Grisham -- a batter who deed .184 successful the regular season. Juan Soto, who deed conscionable six location runs successful 52 games with the Padres, continues to hunt for his powerfulness stroke.

Who's hot: Joe Musgrove and his ears. Red hot, to beryllium precise. Musgrove made the All-Star squad aft a ascendant archetypal fractional successful which helium allowed a .205 mean and .595 OPS, earlier batters deed .254 with a .758 OPS against him successful the 2nd half. He dominated the Mets with 1 deed -- and 1 receptor check -- implicit 7 scoreless innings successful the wild-card bid and past held the Dodgers to 2 runs successful six innings successful the part series.

Who's not: The Padres' rotation thins retired aft Yu Darvish, Musgrove and Blake Snell. Mike Clevinger drew the shot against the Dodgers successful Game 1 and got knocked retired successful the 3rd inning -- this aft a 6.52 ERA successful September. Sean Manaea mightiness get the adjacent accidental to commencement implicit Clevinger and past Melvin mightiness person to trust heavy connected his bullpen. Nick Martinez, a part-time starter during the season, tin spell aggregate innings and mightiness play a cardinal relation successful the mediate games of this series.

How's the defense? Manny Machado has had an fantabulous postseason with a mates of location runs and vacuum cleaner defence astatine 3rd base. Ha-Seong Kim is an underrated shortstop, and Grisham is arguably the champion halfway fielder successful the majors close present (99th percentile successful outs supra average). The large liability is Soto, who is simply a unspeakable close fielder -- atrocious reads, below-average velocity and seemingly indifferent to playing good retired there. He does person a decent arm, but the antiaircraft metrics (first percentile successful outs supra average) enactment the oculus test. The Padres anticipation the shot doesn't find him successful cardinal moments.

Final thought: The Padres' maestro program to dethrone the Dodgers didn't materialize successful the regular play -- the Dodgers not lone bushed them by 22 games but won each six series. But the Padres won the 1 that counts the astir and volition present really get home-field vantage successful the NLCS implicit the Phillies. If the fans bring the aforesaid vigor and sound they brought against the Dodgers, that's a tiny origin successful their favor. The bullpen is clicking connected each cylinders and the apical 3 starters are pitching well. This bid could travel down to pitching depth, and the Padres person the vantage determination implicit the Phillies. -- Schoenfield


Who volition win?

Padres (7 votes), Phillies (5)

Tristan Cockcroft: Phillies successful 6

MVP: Wheeler

The 1 happening we'll each beryllium talking astir during this series: Either Austin Nola taking member Aaron heavy successful his archetypal at-bat successful Game 2, oregon whether the Padres would've yet won had Fernando Tatis Jr. been disposable this postseason.

Bradford Doolittle: Phillies successful 6

MVP: J.T. Realmuto

The 1 happening we'll each beryllium talking about: How Phillies president of shot operations Dave Dombrowski did it again, assembling a pennant victor with a large payroll and a roster that was incomplete but could flex its prima powerfulness astatine the close time.

Alden Gonzalez: Padres successful 6

MVP: Machado

The 1 happening we'll each beryllium talking about: How San Diego mightiness really, genuinely beryllium a shot town.

Eric Karabell: Phillies successful 6

MVP: Harper

The 1 happening we'll each beryllium talking about: Harper 1, Machado 0.

Tim Keown: Padres successful 7

MVP: Machado

The 1 happening we'll each beryllium talking about: The improbable convergence of endowment and cohesiveness that appeared astir retired of obscurity and carried the Padres to the World Series.

Tim Kurkjian: Padres successful 7

MVP: Machado

The 1 happening we'll each beryllium talking about: How the Padres -- who, successful aboriginal August, were expected to beryllium an violative instrumentality -- won with large pitching.

Joon Lee: Padres successful 7

MVP: Musgrove

The 1 happening we'll each beryllium talking about: The Padres' roster depth, overcoming the suspension of Tatis Jr., and showing that getting assertive astatine the commercialized deadline tin beryllium the quality betwixt a wild-card exit and making the World Series.

Kiley McDaniel: Phillies successful 7

MVP: Nola

The 1 happening we'll each beryllium talking about: The Dombrowski look works again -- and the 76ers/Eagles are good, too!

Buster Olney: Padres successful 6

MVP: Soto

The 1 happening we'll each beryllium talking about: How proprietor Peter Seidler hoisted the Padres into the echelon of elite teams done his tendency to win, giving the OK to expend resources to get Melvin, arsenic good arsenic players similar Machado, Soto, Musgrove, Darvish and Hader -- to sanction a few. Seidler changed the trajectory of the franchise.

Jeff Passan: Padres successful 7

MVP: Soto

The 1 happening we'll each beryllium talking about: The past clip the Padres made a World Series, astir a quarter-century ago, wherever they were promptly swept by the Yankees. For this squad to spell all-in and marque it to the Fall Classic, adjacent without Tatis Jr., is not conscionable a phenomenal result for this play but a portent of a large future.

Jesse Rogers: Phillies successful 6

MVP: Harper

The 1 happening we'll each beryllium talking about: The Phillies' starting unit -- it's arsenic bully arsenic it comes, and adjacent with immoderate question marks successful Philadelphia's bullpen, the Padres won't people overmuch successful the series.

Schoenfield: Padres successful 6

MVP: Machado

The 1 happening we'll each beryllium talking about: The Padres' bullpen. Luis Garcia, Suarez and Hader were each throwing 100 mph laser beams against the Dodgers. If the Padres are starring aft six, those 3 volition instrumentality it home.

Read Entire Article