Why Harvard Medical School is withdrawing from the U.S. News & World Report rankings - Boston.com

College

"The suitability of immoderate peculiar aesculapian schoolhouse for immoderate fixed pupil is excessively complex, nuanced, and individualized to beryllium served by a rigid ranked list, nary substance the methodology."

Pedestrians locomotion towards Harvard Medical School successful Boston. Charles Krupa/Associated Press

Harvard Medical School volition nary longer enactment successful the annual “best aesculapian schools” survey and rankings conducted by U.S. News & World Report. The determination was announced by Dean of the Faculty of Medicine George Daly successful a missive published Tuesday. 

Daly’s determination and the concerns that prompted it “rest connected the principled content that rankings cannot meaningfully bespeak the precocious aspirations for acquisition excellence, postgraduate preparedness, and compassionate and equitable diligent attraction that we strive to foster successful our aesculapian acquisition programs,” helium said successful the letter. 

In the 2023 aesculapian schoolhouse rankings, Harvard Medical School was ranked first for probe and ninth for superior care. 

Daly said that helium has been contemplating this determination since helium became dean six years ago, but was compelled to enactment by the actions of Harvard Law School and different notable instrumentality schools. 

Harvard and Yale instrumentality schools announced successful November that they would nary longer beryllium participating successful the rankings. This was a large stroke to the U.S. News rankings, which has published influential lists of the country’s colleges and universities for years. The rankings are meant to assistance students “narrow their assemblage search,” but critics person raised concerns astir the outlet’s methodology and the precise thought of numerically ranking higher acquisition institutions. 

“As unintended consequences, rankings make perverse incentives for institutions to report misleading oregon inaccurate data, acceptable policies to boost rankings alternatively than nobler objectives, oregon divert fiscal aid from students with fiscal request to high-scoring students with means successful bid to maximize ranking criteria,” Daly said successful the letter.

The suitability of immoderate aesculapian schoolhouse is “too complex, nuanced, and individualized to beryllium served by a rigid ranked list, nary substance the methodology,” Daly continued. 

Daly alternatively pointed prospective students toward the Medical School Admission Requirements (MSAR) Reports for Applicants and Advisors, which presents comparable schoolhouse information successful a “raw, unweighted form.”

To rank aesculapian schools, U.S. News uses “faculty resources, the world achievements of entering students and qualitative assessments by schools and residency directors.”